BookmarkBookmarkTick

Doctors Take Issue With Term ‘3-Person Baby’ — Here’s Why

ByAnisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Updated
March 2, 2017
Hero Image

The U.K.'s recent approval of the “three-person baby” IVF procedure is a progressive step for fertility. So why are so many people expressing their aversion? Doctors think it has something to do with what we’re calling it.

Yes, the practice does involve using DNA from three different parents. During the IVF process, any faulty mitochondrial DNA from a fertilized egg is removed and replaced with DNA from a donor, eliminating baby’s risk of inheriting a genetic mitochondrial disease. That’s a good thing — faulty mitochondria can lead to serious problems like seizures, brain damage and heart failure. But the idea of involving three parents makes this process seem too unnatural to opponents, who claim prospective parents are “playing God” and designing our own babies.

“This will be the first time that we would intentionally manipulate the human genome," says David King of watch-dog group Human Genetics Alert in a statement. "It is something that governments around the world have agreed for the last 20 years that we shouldn’t do. And once you cross that line, then it’s very hard to stop going down the slippery slope to designer babies.”

To get away from this idea of designer babies, neurologist Bruce Cohen says it would be better to use the term “mitochondrial transfer.” What opponents may not realize is doctors aren’t manipulating genes, or really doing anything to the 22,000 genes, for that matter, that make up who you are. They’re strickly working with the 37 mitochondrial genes outside of a cell’s nucleus responsible for organ and tissue function. Only about 0.1 percent of the DNA of a baby born from this procedure would come from an egg donor.

So where do we stand? The British House of Lords still has to approve the bill allowing mitochondrial transfer for it to become a law. And in the U.S., the FDA stalled any further testing on mitochondrial transfer in humans back in 2001. However, scientists think testing is the best way to demonstrate the safety and effectiveness of the procedure, and U.K. approval could be the push we need.

(via PBS)

Related Video
bravo tv star writes book for children explaining infertility

Bravo TV Star’s New Book Wants to Teach Kids IVF Is Totally Normal

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
03/24/2020
actress amy schumer posts about her egg retrieval procedure

Amy Schumer Is Staying Positive Through Egg Retrieval Procedure

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
01/14/2020
amy schumer with chris fischer

Amy Schumer Reveals IVF Struggle and Reaches Out to Fans for Support

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
01/10/2020
mina starsiak hawk opens up about her infertility struggles on instagram

HGTV Star Mina Starsiak Reveals Infertility Struggle and IVF Journey

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
12/12/2019
new parents happily holding their newborn baby

This Picture Book Wants to Teach Kids That IVF Is Completely Normal

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
12/05/2019
chrissy teigen and john legend sitting together at en event

John Legend Gets Real on How IVF Changed His Relationship With Teigen

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
11/15/2019
mom opens up about her decision to have her children via reciprocal ivf

How Reciprocal IVF Let Two Moms Both Be a Part of Creating Their Baby

profile picture of Christina Bailey
Christina Bailey
Co-Creator of Baby Bailey Mama Drama
birthday cake with confetti sprinkles

World’s First IVF Baby Celebrates 41st Birthday

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
07/25/2019
Baby born with genes from three different people.

How a Baby in Greece Was Born With Genes From Three People

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
04/12/2019
woman reflects on her emotional ivf journey

New Mom Reflects on the Emotional Roller Coaster That Is IVF

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
01/08/2019
image of one couple's rainbow baby and the process of ivf represented in the fertility treatment shots.

Powerful IVF Newborn Photo Celebrates Parents' Rainbow Baby

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
08/20/2018
john legend with pregnant wife, chrissy teigen

Chrissy Teigen, Honest as Ever, Defends Fan Who Asks About IVF

profile picture of Laurie Ulster
Laurie Ulster
Contributing Writer
Published
06/29/2018
collage illustrating baby born 4 years after parents death

This Baby Was Born Four Years After His Parents Died

profile picture of Anisa Arsenault
Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
04/12/2018
Article removed.