This Woman's Stillbirth Warns Against At-Home Fetal Doppler Systems

She's sharing her tragedy as a lesson for others.
ByAnisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
Jun 2017
Ultrasound illustration
Photo: Shutterstock

At 9 months pregnant and a week past her due date, Vicki McNelly had an instinct something was wrong in the middle of the night. Before heading to the doctor, she did a self-assessment with a home fetal doppler device. The false sense of reassurance it gave her proved to be a fatal mistake.

McNelly thought she heard her daughter’s heartbeat and went back to bed. But when she couldn’t detect any movement the next morning, she headed to the hospital, where she learned she had lost the baby.

Doctors think McNelly actually heard her own heartbeat, not her baby’s. And that lack of clarity when using a home doppler is part of the reason the FDA has advised against them since 2014:

Fetal ultrasound imaging provides real-time images of the fetus. Doppler fetal ultrasound heartbeat monitors are hand-held ultrasound devices that let you listen to the heartbeat of the fetus. Both are prescription devices designed to be used by trained healthcare professionals. They are not intended for over-the-counter (OTC) sale or use, and the FDA strongly discourages their use for creating fetal keepsake images and videos.

At-home doppler systems, which can be purchased for as low as $30, can offer false peace of mind, in McNelly’s case, or a false sense of alarm if you’re not quite sure what you’re looking for. The main problem OBs cite, however, is the risk the excessive sound rays can pose on baby.

“Most handheld fetal dopplers use ultrasound technology to find and listen to the baby’s heartbeat,” says Kristin Mallon, CNM, MS, RNC-OB. “Ultrasound technology uses sound waves to determine images and sounds and is a type of mechanical vibration which is measured in units called hertz or (Hz). Exposure to ultrasound that produces a sound, like a handheld doppler, uses more ultrasound waves than a ultrasound that is producing an image only, so this is something to keep in mind if using them at home. And while, exposure to ultrasound technology in pregnancy has not been shown to have any adverse effects on children exposed to ultrasound in utero, it should still only be used for a clear indication or per your provider’s recommendation.”

The risk of exposing baby to unnecessary waves—and raising tissue temperatures as a result—prompted the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) to extend a warning further than home doppler use. As more and more women seek out scans beyond what their doctors typically provide, often for keepsake sonogram purposes, ACOG issued a committee opinion:

The potential for risk shows that ultrasonography should be used prudently and only when its use is expected to answer a relevant clinical question or otherwise provide medical benefit to the patient. When used in this manner and with machines that are configured correctly, ultrasonography does not pose a risk to the fetus or the pregnancy.

You can learn more about the types of ultrasounds pregnant women typically get, and when, here. As a general rule, a low-risk pregnancy usually warrants three to four ultrasounds.

So if you’re not advised to track baby’s heartbeat with a doppler advise, what can you do for peace of mind at home? Kick counts are a great alternative. And one woman recently claimed kick counts saved her baby’s life.

H/T Daily Mail

Early Pregnancy Loss Often Triggers Post-Traumatic Stress, Study Finds

Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
01/15/2020

Survey Shows Too Many Women Feel Responsible for Miscarriage

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
04/25/2018

After Miscarriages, James Van Der Beek and Wife Are Expecting Baby #6

Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
10/08/2019

James Van Der Beek and Wife Suffer Another Miscarriage

Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
11/19/2019

This Garden Is a Sanctuary for Families Who've Lost a Child

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
12/28/2017

Watch This Tear-Jerking Rainbow Baby Reaction

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
12/20/2017

Autoimmune Disease and Miscarriage?

Jackie Gutmann, MD, reproductive endocrinologist, Reproductive Medicine Associates of Philadelphia
Fertility Specialist

Photographer Explains What It's Like to Document a Newborn's Final Hours of Life

Christine Cordova
Associate Social Editor
Published
07/13/2017

Yeast Infection Drug During Pregnancy Draws Concern From FDA

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
04/27/2016

New Law Offers Parents in the UK Bereavement Leave for Stillborn Babies

Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
09/19/2018

Australian Study Finds a Possible Cause of Stillbirth

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
09/19/2017

This Woman's Stillbirth Warns Against At-Home Fetal Doppler Systems

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
06/30/2017
Advertisement