Got Breast Milk? It's No One's Business if You Share It

save article
profile picture of Jessica Shortall
By Jessica Shortall, Contributing Writer
Updated September 18, 2016
Hero Image
Image: Shutterstock

Meet Jessica Shortall, a working mom with a career dedicated to the intersection of business and doing good. As the former Director of Giving for TOMS Shoes, she literally circumnavigated the globe with a breast pump.  Pre-order her upcoming book by Abrams, “Work. Pump. Repeat: The New Mom’s Guide to Breastfeeding and Going Back to Work,” out Sept. 8.

We seem to be on some sort of mandatory schedule of One Breastfeeding “Controversy” Per Week these days. This week, it’s an “uproar” over a Pennsylvania woman who, with her friend’s enthusiastic consent, has been nursing her own son and her friend’s son for over a year.

I have a bias in this one because I, too, have shared my milk with others. I’m a supporter of the Mothers’ Milk Bank at Austin, a life-saving organization that sends donated breast milk to medically fragile and premature babies. So I already come from a place of knowing — scientifically — that safely sharing breastmilk with babies who need it is a really, really good thing. I have been a milk donor in multiple ways —to the Milk Bank, to a neighbor who couldn’t physically nurse her newborn son for a short period of time, and to a co-worker who had a dwindling freezer stash and needed some mental relief from worrying about it. Each time I shared this great thing my body was making, I felt an enormous sense of connection to other mothers. I was giving them not just a healthy substance for their babies, but also peace of mind, and I am a huge believer in supporting other mothers whenever we can.

And yet, there’s not typically an uproar over women donating breastmilk in a safe way. Why is that? What could possibly be different about nursing a child versus pumping and donating breastmilk? Think hard…think about it…what could it be…?

Related Video

Ahh, yes: breasts. Literally the only difference is milk coming from breasts rather than via a pump and bottle. The milk is the same, the generosity and sharing are the same, and the consent of both mothers is the same. It’s totally fine if we use a piece of farm equipment to get the milk out. The problem is the breasts. It’s always the breasts.

Of course it comes down to breasts, because breasts are sexual. Every billboard and movie and magazine tells us so. They are only for consumption by other grownups. Therefore, that woman offering her breast to another woman’s baby is creepy and inappropriate.

Doesn’t it always seem to come back to our bodies, and what we’re “allowed” to do with them? Don’t nurse in public. Don’t drink coffee while you’re pregnant. Breastfeed your baby no matter what the mental health consequences to you. Do, don’t, do, don’t: the list of instructions to a woman on how she is allowed to use her body related to her baby is long and getting longer.

So here’s my last word on it: When we use our breasts to feed babies — biologically ours or otherwise —it is not a sexual act. Everyone: take one big step back from the mamas, and go mind your business.

*The Bump Note:

The FDA cautions parents who are interested in milk sharing to consult a healthcare professional beforehand and make sure they are using screened milk. Using contaminated milk, whether purchased online or from an individual, can lead to the transfer of infectious diseases or chemical contaminants.

save article

Next on Your Reading List

Andy Cohen attends The Real Housewives of New York Premiere Celebration at The Rainbow Room on July 12, 2023 in New York City.
Andy Cohen Shares Why Toddlers Are Harder to Deal With Than Housewives
By Wyndi Kappes
mother reading with baby on rocking chair in nursery room
Inchstones Is the Biggest Parenting Trend for 2024, Pinterest Says
By Wyndi Kappes
black mother holding baby at home
How Black Parents Can Avoid the Trap of Toxic Positivity
Fact Checked by G. O’Hara
21 Special Kwanzaa Gifts for All of Your Loved Ones
By Ayn-Monique Klahre
jennifer garner and her children next to a headshot of jennifer garner on the red carpet
Jennifer Garner on Why “a Little Benign Neglect” Is the Key Parenting
By Wyndi Kappes
baby tooth in child's hand
Toss or Treasure: Jake Johnson Sparks Debate on Keeping Baby's Teeth
By Wyndi Kappes
mom and baby dancing in living room
Kid's Music Ruining Your Spotify Wrapped? These Parents Can Relate
By Wyndi Kappes
36 matching family pajamas for the holidays and beyond-hero
36 Matching Family Pajamas for the Holidays and Beyond
By The Bump Editors
42 Gifts for Pregnant Women That Are Cute and Congratulatory
By Martina Garvey
hanukkah gifts hero
The Best Hanukkah Gift Ideas for Babies, Toddlers and Caregivers
By Cassie Kreitner
gratitude tablecloth for thanksgiving
The Viral Gratitude Tablecloth Tradition You Can Try This Thanksgiving
By Wyndi Kappes
friends giving pregnant woman gifts
45 Best Mom-To-Be Gifts That Celebrate Her
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
mom talking to son
The Parenting Hack Going Viral: Mastering the 'When/Then' Reframe
By Wyndi Kappes
mom and dad holding newborn baby at home
Viral Post Shares How to Raise Your First Baby Like It’s Your Third
By Wyndi Kappes
mombies dancing to raise money this halloween
Meet the “Mombies” Raising Money for Cancer Research
By Wyndi Kappes
kids trick or treating for halloween
These Are the Top 15 States for Trick-or-Treating in 2023
By Wyndi Kappes
Christmas Gifts for Grandparents Hero
36 Festive and Fun Christmas Gifts for Grandparents
By Danielle Halibey
Christmas Gifts for Parents Hero
45 Christmas Gifts for Parents on the Nice List
By Martina Garvey
New Dad Gifts-hero
The Best Gifts for New Dads to Suit Any Budget
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
Breast Cancer Awareness Hero
14 Gifts That Give Back for Breast Cancer Awareness
By Martina Garvey
Article removed.
Article removed.
Name added. View Your List