CircleBumpCheckedFilledMedicalBookmarkBookmarkTickBookmarkAddCheckBoxCheckBoxFilled

Physicians Fail to Persuade Parents to Vaccinate, Study Finds

save article
profile picture of Anisa Arsenault
By Anisa Arsenault, Associate Editor
Updated March 2, 2017
Hero Image
Image: iStock

Communication between doctors and parents is essential, but it might not be effective at making change.

In light of the resurgence of the vaccine controversy tied to last year’s measles outbreak, public health professionals are trying harder than ever to get moree parents on board with immunizations. But studies show educating parents on the safety and effectiveness of vaccines usually still won’t convince antivaxxers to change their minds.

Seattle’s  Group Health Research Institute  decided to see if coaching doctors on effective parent communication could make a difference.

“The intervention was designed to involve parents and respect where they were coming from, respect that they wanted what was best for their child and the provider wanted that, too,” study lead author, Nora Henrikson, tells KQED’s news blog State of Health. Vaccinations would still be strongly recommended.

In spite of a 45-minute training session for doctors and additional written materials and emails, the intervention was a bust.

Of the 347 mothers of newborns involved in the study, there were no statistical differences in vaccination rates between women placed in clinics where doctors had received the training compared to women placed in other clinics.

“Obviously we were hopeful that it would improve vaccine hesitancy, so we would have preferred to see a different effect,” Henrikson says. “But it really raised more questions about what other projects we could do moving forward.”

Next steps include focusing even more on those who are neither antivaxxers nor pro-vaccines.

“There are people in between,” says Henrikson, “and we’re still understanding that, and at what point do people really have all the information they need?”

Please note: The Bump and the materials and information it contains are not intended to, and do not constitute, medical or other health advice or diagnosis and should not be used as such. You should always consult with a qualified physician or health professional about your specific circumstances.

save article
ADVERTISEMENT

Next on Your Reading List

doctor listening to 1 month old baby's heart
What to Expect at Baby’s One Month Checkup
Medically Reviewed by Dina DiMaggio Walters, MD
doctor giving a baby a vaccine
The AAP Recommends New RSV Shot for Babies and Calls for Equal Access
By Wyndi Kappes
doctor examining one year old baby during 12 month check up
What to Expect at Baby’s 12-Month Checkup
By Anisa Arsenault
ADVERTISEMENT
doctor giving baby a vaccine
FDA Approves COVID-19 Vaccines for Kids 6 Months and Up
By Wyndi Kappes
close up of doctor putting band aid on baby's leg after flu shot
Should Babies Get the Flu Shot? Here’s What to Know
By Lexi Dwyer
Celebrity Alyssa Milano pictured with children during UNICEF volunteer trip to Kosovo.
Alyssa Milano on Parenting, the Pandemic and Working With UNICEF USA
By Lauren Kay
baby being examined by doctor with stethescope
Tool: Vaccine Planner
By The Bump Editors
ADVERTISEMENT
nervous woman stands by window
Study Shows Many Parents Still Don’t Trust Routine Childhood Vaccines
By Nehal Aggarwal
mom holding her baby after it had a vaccine
New Technique Makes Vaccines Safe in Warmer Temperatures, Study Finds
By Nehal Aggarwal
city of boston historic buildings
These Are the Best and Worst States for Vaccination Rates, Report Says
By Nehal Aggarwal
ADVERTISEMENT
sad teddy bear looking out rainy window
Measles Virus Completely Wipes Out Your Immune System, Studies Find
By Nehal Aggarwal
phone screen that shows mock up of vaccine pop up
Facebook and Instagram Debut New Strategy to Combat Vaccine Myths
By Laurie Ulster
two women having serious conversation
How to Talk About Vaccines Without Starting a Fight
By Stephanie Grassullo
ADVERTISEMENT
new york city's empire state building covered by dots that resemble measles rash
CDC: Measles Cases Have Now Hit a More Than 25-Year High
By Stephanie Grassullo
bar graph showing growth
Report: These Places in the US Have the Highest Risk of a Measles Outbreak
By Stephanie Grassullo
woman's hand holding her phone, which shows instagram icon and a vaccine
Instagram Doubles Down Efforts to Stop the Spread of Misinformation on Vaccines
By Stephanie Grassullo
Q&A: Modified Immunization Schedule?
Q&A: Modified Immunization Schedule?
By Dr. Cheryl Wu
ADVERTISEMENT
Little boy with bandaid on arm looking at camera
NYC Declares Public Health Emergency, Orders Mandatory Measles Vaccinations
By Stephanie Grassullo
young school children sitting with their arms around each other
Italy Will Now Ban Unvaccinated Kids From School
By Stephanie Grassullo
medical researcher performing tests in a lab
Massive New Study Once Again Proves No Link Between Vaccines and Autism
By Stephanie Grassullo
ADVERTISEMENT
Article removed.
Article removed.
Name added. View Your List