Point & Counterpoint: Alternate Vaccine Schedule

Should you stick to the Center for Disease Control and American Academy of Pediatrics’ recommended plan for baby’s shots or go for a modified schedule? Check out what two doctors have to say and decide for yourself.Plus:Vaccinations: What Baby Gets WhenAre Vaccines Safe?Modified Immunization Schedule?Vaccine Fears
save article
profile picture of undefined
Updated April 3, 2017
Hot Topic: Alternate Vaccine Schedule
Image: Thinkstock

Alternative Schedules Are Safe

Robert W. Sears, MD

There’s a demand for alternative schedules. Many new parents feel overwhelmed by the number of vaccines given to young babies today; 24 doses are given in the first year alone. When parents realize the medical establishment is trying to push unnecessary vaccines on them, they begin to question the entire process. The result is that parents simply want to vaccinate more carefully, and be smarter about it, instead of blindly following the system.

There’s a Well-Planned Alternative

The alternative schedule [I outline in The Vaccine Book] is designed to provide infants with only the vaccines that protect against diseases that pose a legitimate threat to them. And it does so in a timely manner, so infants aren’t left unprotected against anything that might pose a risk. It provides on-time protection against whooping cough, rotavirus, Hib disease and pneumococcal disease—four illnesses that can be potentially fatal for infants (although fatalities are extremely rare in the US). The CDC schedule gives these four vaccines at two, four and six months (along with Hep B and Polio). My alternative schedule staggers them: whooping cough and rotavirus at two, four and six months; Hib and pneumococcal at three, five and seven months; Hep B is delayed for a few years; and polio isn’t started until nine months.

The only difference between the two approaches is that the alternative schedule is staggered, so fewer doses are given together, with little to no delay in any important vaccines.

Spacing Out Shots Could Prevent Complications

The theoretical advantage to the alternate schedule is it may cause fewer negative reactions, although this hasn’t been proven in research. A second theoretical advantage is that it limits overload of the various chemical ingredients given at any one time. Aluminum, in particular, is better handled by the body when given in smaller amounts spread out over time, instead of larger doses all at once. Aluminum is necessary in many vaccines in order for them to work well, yet it’s known to be toxic when injected in high doses. The same was true for mercury when it was in vaccines, although it hasn’t been used in US vaccines since 2002.

Related Video

No thorough comparison has been done between the CDC schedule and my alternative one in regard to reactions. It is my opinion, however, that giving only two shots at a time is much better tolerated than giving six vaccines together.

Worried Parents Are More Likely to Vaccinate with an Adjusted Schedule

The advantages of the alternative schedule are, admittedly, theoretical. Yet in my experience, many parents who choose not to vaccinate do so because they don’t want to overload their babies. When offered a more gradual approach, they are more compliant and vaccine rates increase.

Delayed Shots Are the Unimportant Ones

I don’t delay any vaccines that protect against diseases that are a clear and present danger. For example, delaying Hepatitis B doesn’t pose any risk. Delaying polio for several months doesn’t either, as we don’t have polio in the US. A delay in Hepatitis A is also not a risk, as this is a harmless disease in children. Diseases that are extremely rare, have been eliminated from our country or are generally mild when contracted are less important to vaccinate against.

Robert W. Sears, MD, is a pediatrician in Orange County, CA, and author of The Vaccine Book: Making the Right Decision for Your Child

They Leave Baby Vulnerable To Disease

Daniel P. McGee, MD

If you’re on an alternate schedule, you’re just delaying protection. These are preventable diseases, and they strike hardest in younger children. For example, there was a recent whooping cough outbreak. Whooping cough particularly is more severe in babies; their tiny airways are small and their respiratory systems can’t handle it. For adults, it might just be a hacking cough, but for a little infant, she might need to be put on a ventilator. Some babies even die from it.

It’s Not Scientifically Backed

Stick to the AAP schedule. There’s no science to say it’s better or safer to spread out the shots. Plus, you are delaying protection at the time when babies need it most.

I’ve looked closely at the alternative schedule, and I’ve wondered what it’s based on. It seems like it just kind of looked good. There appears to be no scientific basis—just that it’s more spread out than a typical schedule, and it requires more doctor visits.

Overexposure to Immunizations Isn’t a Thing

The multiple antigen theory is kind of a joke. I tell parents who are concerned about giving multiple shots at once that every time their child falls onto the carpet, they’re exposed to more antigens than they are when they get vaccinated.

Side effects do occur. We see some fevers and swelling at the injection site, but it’s very rare to have a severe reaction. In any case, getting the disease would have a much more negative effect and would be worse for a child than any side effect.

It’s also important to note that you don’t get any protection from an immunization that’s a series of shots until you’ve had all three of the shots.

Yes, there is something daunting about a child getting five shots in a single visit. It can be intimidating. But after seeing children with the diseases that vaccines can prevent, I must say they get much more poking when they have those diseases than they will get with shots.

Nope, More Visits to the Doctor Make It Harder to Keep Up

The alternative schedule is a lot, and it gets confusing. You have to make 19 visits to the doctor before the child is six years old. There are 12 visits before the age of two. The more visits you have to make, the less likely you are to comply with it. Missing vaccines just puts your child at risk.

All Vaccines Are Important

All it would take is one unimmunized person to travel to a part of the world where the disease is still present. This happened recently in Brooklyn, New York, with measles, and it can keep happening.

Daniel P. McGee, MD, is a Spectrum Health Medical Group physician who practices as a pediatric hospitalist at Helen DeVos Children’s Hospital in Grand Rapids, MI

Please note: The Bump and the materials and information it contains are not intended to, and do not constitute, medical or other health advice or diagnosis and should not be used as such. You should always consult with a qualified physician or health professional about your specific circumstances.

save article

Next on Your Reading List

doctor evaluating child with measles rash
CDC Urges Parents to Vaccinate Kids Against Measles Amid Rising Cases
By Wyndi Kappes
doctor giving a baby a vaccine
RSV Shot Proves 90 Percent Effective in Preventing Hospitalizations
By Wyndi Kappes
baby being examined by doctor with stethescope
Tool: Baby and Child Immunization Schedule
By The Bump Editors
doctor listening to 1 month old baby's heart
What to Expect at Baby’s One Month Checkup
Medically Reviewed by Dina DiMaggio Walters, MD
doctor examining one year old baby during 12 month check up
What to Expect at Baby’s 12-Month Checkup
By Anisa Arsenault
doctor giving baby a vaccine
FDA Approves COVID-19 Vaccines for Kids 6 Months and Up
By Wyndi Kappes
close up of doctor putting band aid on baby's leg after flu shot
Should Babies Get the Flu Shot? Here’s What to Know
By Lexi Dwyer
Celebrity Alyssa Milano pictured with children during UNICEF volunteer trip to Kosovo.
Alyssa Milano on Parenting, the Pandemic and Working With UNICEF USA
By Lauren Kay
nervous woman stands by window
Study Shows Many Parents Still Don’t Trust Routine Childhood Vaccines
By Nehal Aggarwal
mom holding her baby after it had a vaccine
New Technique Makes Vaccines Safe in Warmer Temperatures, Study Finds
By Nehal Aggarwal
city of boston historic buildings
These Are the Best and Worst States for Vaccination Rates, Report Says
By Nehal Aggarwal
sad teddy bear looking out rainy window
Measles Virus Completely Wipes Out Your Immune System, Studies Find
By Nehal Aggarwal
phone screen that shows mock up of vaccine pop up
Facebook and Instagram Debut New Strategy to Combat Vaccine Myths
By Laurie Ulster
two women having serious conversation
How to Talk About Vaccines Without Starting a Fight
By Stephanie Grassullo
new york city's empire state building covered by dots that resemble measles rash
CDC: Measles Cases Have Now Hit a More Than 25-Year High
By Stephanie Grassullo
bar graph showing growth
Report: These Places in the US Have the Highest Risk of a Measles Outbreak
By Stephanie Grassullo
woman's hand holding her phone, which shows instagram icon and a vaccine
Instagram Doubles Down Efforts to Stop the Spread of Misinformation on Vaccines
By Stephanie Grassullo
Q&A: Modified Immunization Schedule?
Q&A: Modified Immunization Schedule?
By Dr. Cheryl Wu
Little boy with bandaid on arm looking at camera
NYC Declares Public Health Emergency, Orders Mandatory Measles Vaccinations
By Stephanie Grassullo
young school children sitting with their arms around each other
Italy Will Now Ban Unvaccinated Kids From School
By Stephanie Grassullo
Article removed.
Article removed.
Name added. View Your List