Bye-bye, Binky! How and When to Take Away the Pacifier

Ready to wean baby off of the pacifier? Here’s how to get you both through the big breakup.
ByLisa Milbrand
Contributing Writer
March 5, 2018
baby laying down with pacifier in mouth
Image: iStock

Some habits are hard to quit—and the pacifier (or binky or whatever your pet name is for it) is definitely one of the hardest for babies. Sure, it provides an endless source of comfort for your little one, but at a certain point he’s gotta learn to live without it. As with any breakup, there will be tears—baby will be missing his binky, you’ll be missing a good night’s sleep—but the good news is, you can both get through this! Follow these trusted tips for tackling pacifier weaning head-on.

When to Take Away the Pacifier

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, when your child is a year old, it may be time to speak with your pediatrician about starting to wean baby from the pacifier. Preeti Parikh, MD, a pediatrician with Pediatrics of New York and an assistant clinical professor in the pediatrics department at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, says after age one, sucking is no longer an important source of soothing. While many toddlers continue using a pacifier for a couple of years beyond that, the AAP says sucking on a pacifier past age 2 to 4 can affect the shape of baby’s mouth and how her teeth align as they come in.

Most kids will stop using pacifiers on their own between the ages of 2 and 4—but others may need some help learning to let go of that little bit of security and soothing. And if your child happens to fall into that camp, don’t wait around for signs she’s ready to give up the paci. “They [may] never show signs!” says Natasha Burgert, MD, a pediatrician with KCKidsDoc in Kansas City, Missouri. “This is most often a parenting choice.”

How to Get Rid of the Pacifier

Kicking the pacifier habit can be a bit of a challenge, and there’s definitely no one-size-fits-all approach that works for every toddler. That said, there are a few pacifier weaning techniques you’ll want to try:

Go cold turkey. Burgert recommends ditching the pacifiers in one fell swoop. “Toddlers have simple minds,” she says. “Either things exist or they don’t. So at the end of the pacifier weaning process, the paci moves from ‘present’ to ‘absent.’ You may as well just make that transition swiftly rather than lengthening it out.”

Set some parameters. Not bold enough to break it off all at once? Start limiting the times and places where baby can use a pacifier—such as only in bed or only if he’s teething.

Try positive reinforcement. The American Dental Association recommends praising baby when she avoids thumb-sucking or using the pacifier; this helps encourage the behavior you want to see.

Trade it for something desirable. Bribery can often be an effective tool for pacifier weaning. Tell your toddler she can trade it in to “pay” for something enticing—like a new toy or a favorite treat.

Don’t cave. Got a stubborn sucker? Once you’ve said you’re getting rid of the pacifier, don’t give in to your toddlers’ demands. “Be quick. Confident. Convicted,” Burgert says. “Regardless of how attached a kid may be, you’ll have three bad nights. That’s it.”

It’s a small price to pay for saying bye-bye to binky for good.

Updated November 2017

Plus more from The Bump, What You Need To Know About Growth Spurts:

end night time feeding, sleeping baby

How to Night Wean Baby

profile picture of Kristina Cappetta
Kristina Cappetta
baby demonstrating one of the nine faces of weaning

9 Faces of Weaning Every Parent Needs to Know, According to Experts

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor

Q&A: How Can I Prevent Mastitis?

profile picture of Nancy Mohrbacher, IBCLC, FILCA
Nancy Mohrbacher, IBCLC, FILCA
Lactation Specialist

Q&A: I'm Trying to Wean, Now What?

profile picture of Jeanne Cygnus, IBCLC, RLC
Jeanne Cygnus, IBCLC, RLC
Lactation Specialist

Q&A: Does Weaning Affect Fertility?

profile picture of Jack Newman, MD, FRCPC
Jack Newman, MD, FRCPC

Q&A: Do I Need to Wean Baby?

profile picture of Jack Newman, MD, FRCPC
Jack Newman, MD, FRCPC
mom cuddling bed baby

How to Stop Breastfeeding (and Keep Baby Happy)

profile picture of Lisa Milbrand
Lisa Milbrand
Contributing Writer
Article removed.