BookmarkBookmarkTick

Heard of 'Transition Formula'? Here's Why Health Professionals Are Against It

"Toddler drinks are unnecessary and may undermine a nutritious diet."
ByAnisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
February 8, 2018
toddler drinking from orange sippy cup
Image: Getty Images

While there are a ton of options, choosing baby food is pretty clear-cut. For starters, infant formula is highly regulated. And from there, solid baby food is broken down and labeled by stage. But as you enter the toddler years, things get a little murkier. Does your child need a transition formula? How is toddler milk different from regular milk? Consider this your reminder that health professionals advise against any drinks with either of those labelings. And to drive that reminder home, a new study is calling for accurate and honest labeling of toddler drinks.

Researchers from New York University and The University of Connecticut teamed up to go to stores and evaluate toddler drink packages, including nutrition labels and claims. They noticed toddler drinks, marketed for children between 9 months and 3 years old, go by a variety of names, most notably “toddler formula,” “transition formula,” “toddler drink," “toddler milk” or "milk drink.” But they all had one thing in common: They boasted at least one health claim on the packaging.

"All product labels made claims related to nutrition and health, and many made claims about expert recommendations that may lead caregivers to believe these products are necessary and healthy,” says study lead author Jennifer L. Pomeranz, JD, MPH. “In fact, they are not recommended by health experts, as there is no evidence that they are nutritionally superior to healthy food and whole milk for toddlers.”

The American Academy of Pediatrics says that toddlers should drink cow’s milk (or these alternatives, if they’re allergic or if your family is dairy-free) from the age of 1 onward, paired with healthy foods. The World Health Organization backs this recommendation, adding that toddler drinks are “unnecessary” and “unsuitable.” Ultimately, these toddler drinks prey on parental fears that their kids need supplemental nutrition. And when they’re manufactured by brands who also make infant formula, it’s easy to believe they’re the natural next step in your toddler’s diet. But in reality, they’re mostly made of powdered milk, corn syrup and other added sweeteners, and contain less protein and more sodium than cow’s milk.

Compared to the legal regulations for how infant formula is marketed (although recent investigations reveal they’re making false health claims anyway), there’s nothing specific for toddler drinks. Researchers are hoping this study, published in journal Preventative Medicine, will help change that.

“Toddler drinks are unnecessary and may undermine a nutritious diet, yet manufacturers have expanded their marketing of these products. Therefore, it is important for labels to be clear, transparent, and accurate,” Pomeranz says. “The FDA and manufacturers should work together to end the inappropriate labeling of toddler drinks and ensure caregivers have reliable information to nutritiously feed their children.”

Is It Okay for My Toddler to Play With Her Food?

profile picture of Elizabeth Pantley
Elizabeth Pantley
Parenting Expert
All different kinds of protein for toddlers including cow's milk, soy milk, almond milk yogurt and cheese.

Ask the Pediatrician: Which Type of Milk Is Best for Toddlers?

profile picture of Dina DiMaggio, MD, and Anthony F. Porto, MD, MPH
Dina DiMaggio, MD, and Anthony F. Porto, MD, MPH
dad feeding his baby at the kitchen table

USDA’s Nutritional Guidelines Now Include Recommendations for Babies

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
07/22/2020
toddler child holding orange sip cup

Preschoolers Who Drink 100% Fruit Juice May Have Healthier Diets as Adults

profile picture of Nehal Aggarwal
Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
06/11/2020

Vitamins for a Picky Eater?

profile picture of Michael Lee, MD, assistant professor of pediatrics at UT Southwestern Medical Center and pediatrician at Children’s Medical Center Dallas
Michael Lee, MD, assistant professor of pediatrics at UT Southwestern Medical Center and pediatrician at Children’s Medical Center Dallas
Pediatrician
small child drinking milk from a bottle

Research Aims to Debunk the 'Milk Causes Mucus Myth’

profile picture of Stephanie Grassullo
Stephanie Grassullo
Associate Editor
Published
09/07/2018
child eating his breakfast cereal

Why Gluten-Free Isn’t Always the Healthier Choice for Kids

profile picture of Dina DiMaggio, MD, and Anthony F. Porto, MD, MPH
Dina DiMaggio, MD, and Anthony F. Porto, MD, MPH
Published
07/30/2018
collage of major soda brands, sprite, coke, fanta

Soda and Sugary Drinks Are Banned From Kids' Menu in Baltimore

profile picture of Laurie Ulster
Laurie Ulster
Contributing Writer
Published
07/20/2018
Young blonde girl picking her nose

Blame Bad Behavior on Bacteria

profile picture of Anisa Arsenault
Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
A dad spoon feeding baby in high chair

AAP Updates List of Nutrients for Baby's First 1,000 Days

profile picture of Anisa Arsenault
Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
01/25/2018
Article removed.