Are Doctors Giving IVF Couples Different Advice When It Comes to Prenatal Testing?

ByKylie McConville
Updated
Mar 2017
Hero Image

Something called the “precious baby” phenomenon has parents-to-be worried that their doctors may be giving different couples conflicting advice, all according to how they conceived.

An international study of 37-year-old moms-to-be recently showed that 45 percent of their doctors recommended an amniocentesis for mom if baby was conceived naturally — and only 19 percent of doctors suggested the procedure to women who had used assisted reproductive technologies (ART) in order to conceive. Why are doctors testing your amniotic fluid anyway? It’s a way for doctors to look at any chromosomal abnormalities and infections while baby’s in utero. Doctors also test for Down Syndrome at this time too. So, what explains the difference in docs who suggest it — and those that don’t? The “precious baby” phenomenon.

“Precious baby” refers to the idea that one baby is more precious than another — based on how she was conceived. But is it really possible? Is one baby more precious than another? We’d like to think not (they’re all precious!), but for some couples — and doctors, that’s apparently just the case.

According to Dr. Yaniv Hanoch, who co-authored the study, it’s not only parents who deem their pregnancies to be more valuable than others, especially if they’ve used technology to help them conceive — more and more, doctors are more likely to be affected by the nature of how their patients got pregnant. Basically, doctors are finding it harder to stay out of mom and dad’s business if they used IVF or another alternative method to conceive, believing that these babies are more “precious” because they were not conceived naturally. “This study demonstrates there may be a tendency for clinicians to be affected by the nature of the pregnancy before determining the parents’ wishes.”

Related Video

In order to collect data, researchers used responses from a questionnaire of nearly 160 OBs and gynecologists. At least a third of the doctors surveyed admitted that they immediately recommended moms-to-be have an amniocentesis, while just 31.3 percent said that they recommended the procedure after receiving further clarification on the high risk to mom and baby. But once researchers probed OBs and gynecologists further, they found that those percentages differed once the “method” of pregnancy was taken into account.  “Even without a medical indication,” the researchers wrote, “more clinicians would recommend amniocentesis to a woman with normal screening test results in a spontaneous pregnancy than to one who had undergone ART. Thus far, researchers have provided only indirect evidence to support the claim of differential management of ART pregnancies, but our findings show they do not appear to be immune to the ‘precious baby’ phenomenon.”

Do you think doctors should consider different risks based on how couple’s conceive?

John Legend Gets Real on How IVF Changed His Relationship With Teigen

Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
11/15/2019

What Is GnRH Agonist?

Peter G. McGovern, MD, director, Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, Newark; medical director of University Reproductive Associates, Montclair, NJ
Fertility Specialist

Remembering the First IVF Mom

Sarah Yang
Published
06/21/2012

Sunlight Boosts IVF Success by Over A Third

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor

This Easy Diet Is Boosting IVF Success Rates

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
01/30/2018

Better Tools to Predict IVF Success

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
04/09/2015

Study Links IVF to Birth Defects

Leah Rocketto
Published
10/23/2012

Couple 'Practices' Parenting With Their Cardboard Box of Embryos

Sarah Hooper
Associate Social Editor
Published
02/06/2018

Embryo Transfer?

John Rinehart, MD, PhD, Reproductive Medicine Institute, Chicago
Fertility Specialist

What Is Ovarian Hyperstimulation?

Peter G. McGovern, MD, director, Division of Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, Newark; medical director of University Reproductive Associates, Montclair, NJ
Fertility Specialist