The Pros (and Cons!) of Making Your Own Baby Food

profile picture of Abigail Green
ByAbigail Green
Updated
Jan 2017
Hero Image
Photo: Francesca Russell Photography

Imagine how much easier it would be to raise kids if you didn’t have to feed them? You could blissfully go about your day without having to purée anything or push green beans on anyone. You wouldn’t have to water down juice, cool off oatmeal, or pick the raisins out of raisin bread. And you wouldn’t have to wipe down a highchair, your kitchen floor, and possibly the walls 3-5 times a day!

Feeding your baby is hard enough without adding more work by making your own baby food, right? I mean, isn’t that what prepackaged meals are for? Well, just like every other aspect of parenting, I changed my tune on this once I had a baby of my own. And just like every other aspect of parenting, there are pros and cons to making your own baby food.

Pro

It’s simple. We’re talking about pureeing a sweet potato, not making C_oq au Vin_. Steaming, mashing, blending — that’s as complicated as baby food needs to be. No spices, complicated ingredients or garnishes necessary.

Con

It’s time-consuming. Yes, it does take more time to wash, peel, steam, and mash some carrots than to pop open a jar. But I know some parents who make a whole bunch of pureed carrots at once, then froze them in ice cube trays for individual servings they can thaw in a jiffy. I was never that organized.

Pro

It’s cheaper. I decided to buy only organic baby food with my second child and let me tell you, that stuff does not come cheap. Plus, it would irk me to look at the ingredients and see that half the jar was water.

Con

It’s not as convenient. Popping a few sealed, no-refrigeration-required jars or pouches of baby food into your diaper bag is way easier, not to mention neater, than packaging and toting your own.

Related Video

Pro

It’s healthier. Store-bought baby food has additives and preservatives and sometimes food coloring to make it appealing and shelf-stable, unlike food you prepare yourself. When you go straight from the farmer’s market to your kitchen, you know what your baby’s eating.

Con

It’s more aggravating. The shopping, chopping, cooking and storing takes time. The mashing and pureeing makes a mess. (Especially if you forget to put on the top of the blender like me!) And then when you’re done, your child might not even like what you’ve made — like my broccoli-cheese muffin debacle. (Tip: Just because your child likes blueberry muffins does _ not _ mean he will gobble down muffins containing stinky green vegetables.)

Of course, there’s no law saying it’s got to be all or nothing. I ended up making most of my baby food and using the store-bought stuff when we were on the go. Or when I was too busy cleaning steamed carrots off the ceiling.

Do you make your own baby food? Why or why not?

The Hidden Danger Inside Baby's Sippy Cup

Anisa Arsenault
Associate Editor
Published
02/24/2016

Q&A: Is My Baby Hungry?

Nancy Mohrbacher, IBCLC, FILCA
Lactation Specialist

Q&A: Can Baby Drink From a Cup?

Jack Newman, MD, FRCPC
Pediatrician

Q&A: Nighttime Feedings While Away?

Nancy Mohrbacher, IBCLC, FILCA
Lactation Specialist

The Pros and Cons of Pacifier Use

Yelena Moroz Alpert
Contributing Writer

What to Know About Infant Tongue Tie

Anna Davies
Contributing Writer

95 Percent of Major Baby Food Brands Contain Toxic Metals, Study Says

Nehal Aggarwal
Associate Editor
Published
10/18/2019

Q&A: Keeping Baby Hydrated?

Nancy Mohrbacher, IBCLC, FILCA
Lactation Specialist

Milk Protein Intolerance in Babies

Jennifer L.W. Fink
Registered Nurse
Advertisement