10 Best Wearable & Hands-Free Breast Pumps, Tested by Nursing Moms
In a nutshell:
Based on feedback from our team of independent product testers, a survey of over 300 parents from The Bump community and advice from two lactation consultants, we chose the Lansinoh Discreet Duo as the overall best wearable breast pump. In particular, this pump stood out for its innovative technology, discreet size and an output comparable to standard electric pumps. The Momcozy V1 Pro is our pick for best overall hands-free pump due to its outstanding suction power, increased milk output and minimal parts to wash.
As a breastfeeding mom of two and a work-from-home wife who’s with my kids all day, my daily routine is filled with loads of laundry, business Zoom meetings, grabbing snacks for my toddler and bouncing around my 6-month-old—all while either feeding or pumping every two hours. If I didn’t have a wearable pump, I’m not sure how I could do it all. I’m in the phase of life right now where I simply can’t be tethered to a wall with an electric pump during the day.
Francie Webb, IBCLC, a certified lactation consultant and doula, says many moms want portability with their pumps. “Most of what people want today are wearables. It’s like, why wouldn’t I want to be able to use my hands?” she says. For modern moms who have so much to do, the convenience of wearable and hands-free pumps is beyond valuable—so valuable, in fact, that wearables seem to have overtaken electric breast pumps as the most popular pump style on the market today.
Whether you’re returning to work or simply don’t want to be confined to one spot while you pump, we’ve personally tested the leading options with the latest features and technology to help you find the best wearable or hands-free pump for you.
This article includes recommendations for wearable and hands-free breast pumps. If you’re looking for a standard electric or manual option, check out our reviews of the best electric breast pumps and best manual breast pumps.
The Bump editors conducted extensive research to identify 28 top-rated manual breast pumps on the market. After reviewing the features, functionalities and specs of each and how they address the specific needs of breastfeeding moms, we then chose a shortlist of 20 products to test. From there:
- I and 10 other independent product testers personally tested the wearable and hands-free breast pumps during our regular day-to-day routines. My milk supply is fairly consistent in the afternoon, so I made sure to compare all of my pumping sessions around 1 p.m. each day. Then, we reviewed and scored each pump based on its ease of use, effectiveness, comfort, noise, quality, style and design and value for money.
- We surveyed over 300 new parents in The Bump community for additional insight into the pumps they’ve used and what they did and didn’t like about them.
- We interviewed four lactation consultants to better understand use cases and essential features to keep in mind as you shop for and use a wearable or hands-free breast pump, as well as the pros and cons of every type of breast pump.
- Because no two moms are the same, we scoured forums, social media channels, message boards and customer reviews to see how these pumps performed for a wide range of moms.
Editorial integrity is at the heart of everything we publish. Read about how The Bump develops our product reviews.
Overall best wearable breast pump
- 100% free through most insurance plans
- Gentle on breasts
- Great milk output
- Hospital-strength suction
- Gets slightly louder on a higher setting
- Shorter battery life
For the second year in a row, the Lansinoh DiscreetDuo Wearable Pump holds the title as our Best of The Bump winner for overall best wearable breast pump. (See all of this year’s Best of The Bump winners.) It has everything you need in a fantastic wearable: It’s quiet and discreet, gentle yet powerful, has few parts to wash and one heck of a milk output. (About as much as fellow mom and product tester Christine usually gets from her standard electric breast pump!) Nothing we’ve tested this far has quite lived up to the performance of the Lansinoh DiscreetDuo Wearable Pump.
As a breastfeeding mom myself, I’m particularly juiced to hear about this pump’s comfort, which Christine says is top-notch. “This is one of the most comfortable breast pumps I've ever used,” she says, “with no discomfort even on the higher power settings.” Christine was really impressed that she could amp up the pumping speed and still feel only a gentle pull on her breasts. Strong and gentle wearable pumps like this one are the reason why more moms are passing on the big, bulky wall plug electric pumps. Because why opt for something that ties you down when you could have it all in a compact, cordless option?
But perhaps one of the most standout features of The DiscreetDuo Wearable Pump is how few pieces and parts there are to it. I’ve been through my fair share of wearable pumps that come with about a dozen pieces, rushing to wash them all in between a hundred other daily tasks. You don’t get that stress with Lansinoh. There are five parts total per pump—and only four to wash. Christine says they took less than a minute to put together when she needed to pump. “And once they were together, I felt confident walking around while getting some things done around the house, while pumping and experienced no leaking whatsoever,” she adds.
The noise level wasn’t the quietest out of all the pumps we tested, but it was still very soft. And it even charges up quickly with a common household C-charger. For the biggest, reddest cherry on top, though, it does all of this and more for only $160 and is fully covered by most health insurance plans (including Medicaid)—meaning this top-rated wearable could cost you nothing!
For more information, check out our in-depth review of the Lansinoh Discreet Duo.
Dimensions (single pump): 7" (L) x 6.3" (W) x 5.5" (H) | Weight (single pump): 8 oz. | Battery life: 100 minutes | Milk capacity: 6 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 21mm and 24mm
Our product tester says:
“This pump yielded exactly what I get with my standard electric pump. The milk was collected in under 20 minutes, and I was able to wash dishes and clean up my kitchen while the pump stayed secure inside my nursing bra.”
Best budget-friendly wearable breast pump
- Priced lower than most wearables
- 12 levels of suction strength
- Only four parts to clean
- Comes with extra pumping goodies
- Duckbill valve placement can be awkward
This one goes down in the books as my favorite bargain in the wearable pump world. Not only did the MomMed S21 produce about the same amount of breast milk as I’d typically pump with a professional hospital-grade electric pump, and comes with so many bonus goodies other brands don’t inlude—pumping bra extender straps, a scrubber cleaner, milk storage bags, carrying bags and multiple flange sizes—but it’s also priced at under $120. You get tons of value with the MomMed S21 wearable breast pump, our Best of The Bump winner for best budget-friendly wearable breast pump.
The S21 features a lightweight design that secures to your breasts nicely—to the point where I almost forgot I was pumping while I was busy chasing my toddler around. This security comes from MomMed’s silicone flange backing, which feels oh-so-soft and suctions right into place. I could bend over, do the dishes and play with my toddler without them moving around. As a busy mom, it’s fantastic. And as a brand new mom, you get the added benefit of an included flyer sheet on how to increase your breast milk and a guide that helps you learn how to successfully breastfeed. I could really tell MomMed put in the extra effort to support nursing moms.
Usually, lower-priced wearable pumps come with their issues. The first wearable pump I bought with my eldest child was for a low price, and it proved to be as cheap as it was inexpensive. I’m still not sure where the thing is today because it let me down so much. But with the MomMed S21, the lower price point doesn’t come at the expense of getting the job done, and it does it darn well. I did have to fiddle with the duckbill valves to get them on each time, but it’s a small price to pay for a pump that checks all the boxes while still being affordable.
Dimensions (single pump): 4.8" (L) x 4.3" (W) x 2.7" (H) | Weight (single pump): 8 oz. | Battery life: 2.5 hours | Milk capacity: 6 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 17mm, 19mm and 21mm
Our product tester says:
“One thing I was really surprised about was everything that came with this pump. It feels like you have everything you need to start pumping and finish up—there’s so much value in this pump set, way more than the other wearable pumps I tried.”
Most discreet wearable breast pump
- Slimmest pump on the market
- Case doubles as a charging unit
- Transparent window for nipple alignment
- Real-time pump tracking
- Assembling the pump takes getting used to
Momcozy makes fantastic wearable pumps. In fact, five of my mom friends have wearable Momcozies—including me! The Momcozy I got through my insurance turned out to be amazing, so when I tried out their new Air 1 I knew it was going to be good. It’s marketed as the slimmest wearable pump on the market, and when I physically laid all the wearable pumps I tested for The Bump together, the Air 1 indeed proved to be the thinnest. Not only is it a shockingly slim 2.4 inches thick, but the shape of the cup also won me over. You don’t get that awkward look you can sometimes get from other wearables that resemble a bowl under your shirt. The Air 1 gives more of a natural breast shape. If I went out and about with these on, I wouldn't feel awkward at all because they look great under my clothes.
Slim as it is, the first thing that caught my eye about the Air 1 was the portable charging case. You can think of it like AirPods that snap right into their case and charge when you’re not using them—pure genius. And while the cases can’t hold every single one of the extras that come with the pump, it offers a great solution to charge your pumps on the go. Impressively, the case's charge supports 15 pumping sessions, equivalent to five days of use. But the techy upgrades don’t stop there either. The included app connects to each pump via Bluetooth, allowing you to adjust all your settings and track your milk output in the app, all while auto-storing your pumped amounts in a dedicated tracker.
All in all, the Momcozy Air 1 is made for the mom who wants to pump discreetly in style while having the best technology that today’s modern pumps offer. If that sounds like you, the Air 1 should be on your radar. It's definitely on ours, as a Best of The Bump award winner for most discreet wearable breast pump.
Dimensions (single pump): 4.9" (L) x 2.67" (W) x 4.33" (H) | Weight (single pump): 9.8 oz. | Battery life: 3 hours | Milk capacity: 6 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 17mm, 19mm and 21mm
Our product tester says:
“This pump is really, really comfy! [The cups and motors] aren’t bulky or get in the way. Even when I was cooking dinner and moving around, I could do it all. They fit so great in my nursing bra, unlike others that seem to fall out because they are so big.”
Best quiet wearable breast pump
- Minimal noise, certified by Quiet Mark
- Strong suction
- Smart pumping rhythms
- Higher price point than competitors
- Our tester had difficulties connecting the pump to her app at first
This pump is “so quiet, you can hear a milk drop”—at least, that’s what Elvie claims. The good news is, our product tester happily confirms that it’s true. Mannibell, a mom to a 2-month-old, says the Elvie’s noise levels are so low that “it’s not even noticeable when you’re pumping.” In fact, Elvie is the only wearable breast pump officially certified by Quiet Mark, a scientific acoustics team that tests small appliances for noise levels. At only 32 decibels, that’s about as quiet as the hum of a refrigerator. No wonder it received a Best of The Bump award for best quiet wearable breast pump. And if you need further convincing, Elvie even published a video showing other common pumps side by side with theirs, so you can hear the differences for yourself.
At half a pound per pump, it’s one of the lightest wearable pumps on our list and almost undetectable. This was a big hit with Mannibell, who raves, “When using [it], I don’t feel like I have anything on, which is great.” Don’t be fooled, though. The Elvie wearable doesn’t slack in the power department. “This is the first wearable breast pump that actually works for me,” Mannibell reports. “It has great suction, so it collects a lot in a shorter amount of time.” The customizable settings (which can be controlled via an app on your phone) provide four different rhythms to adapt your pumping experience to your own personal needs. So, whether you have a heavy letdown and strong output or need a more sensitive and gentle approach, there’s a setting catered to you.
Now the elephant in the room: Elvie is one of the most expensive wearable pumps we’ve tested. At about $550, moms might not be able to drop that kind of money on a breast pump. However, the price is backed by some pretty neat technology. I think one of the coolest features is its infrared sensors, which detect your letdown and automatically switch to expression mode. I can see this optimizing your pumping sessions so you get the most milk out of each pump.
It’s also worth noting that Elvie was recently acquired by Willow, another leading FemTech brand. What does this mean for Elvie buyers? At the moment, not much! Willow says that they intend to keep the Elvie brand name active—great news!
Dimensions (single pump): 4.3" (L) x 2.7" (W) x 5" (H) | Weight (single pump): 8 oz. | Battery life: 2.5 hours | Milk capacity: 5 fl. oz. | Flanges included: 24mm and 28mm
Our product tester says:
“The quality is great! It’s easy to use and gets the job done. …It is a bit pricey, but worth every penny since it does its work beautifully.”
Our community says:
It's a very quiet pump, easy to operate and very effective. – Laura, mother of two and The Bump survey respondent
Best leak-proof wearable breast pump
- Leak-proof, even when bending or lying down
- Lightweight and discreet
- Can be turned on and off from iPhone and Apple Watch
- Option to pump directly into bags
- Pricey
- According to our tester, the app measured more milk than she actually produced
- Only comes with one charger for two pumps
The last thing you want is for your pump to start leaking on you. The first wearable pump I ever used ended up spilling my liquid gold all over my shirt as I was pumping—not the kind of letdown I was looking for. The thing with wearable pumps is that if they aren’t made with extra thought and care, this can be a common experience. Thankfully, the Willow 360 is a workhorse that won’t waste a drop of that hard-earned breast milk, no matter what position you find yourself in—literally! Willow says it’s the only wearable breast pump with a 100 percent leak-proof latch, meaning you can lie down and fully bend over without spilling a drop. Our product tester, Troy M., a mom of seven children, tried the Willow 360 for her 1-month-old baby and confirmed that the pump doesn’t leak, even while bending down, earning it a Best of The Bump award for best leak-proof wearable breast pump.
The Willow 360 offers hospital-grade power with seven levels of smart suction that can be controlled and adjusted via the Willow app (or even an Apple Watch). “The ability to adjust suction levels from the app is awesome. No need to dig in my bra to make changes or power it down,” our tester says. Even better, this pump received a 10 out of 10 rating for ease of use. Troy notes this pump was extremely straightforward to assemble, saying, “I love that there weren’t a bunch of pieces, just two!” As someone who's personally tested over a dozen pumps, I can say from experience that washing and assembling a pump with only two parts is a big selling point for me. Round it all out with the fact that the Willow is clinically tested and FDA-approved, and you’ve got yourself an all-around fantastic pump.
Dimensions (single pump): 5.5" (L) x 4.4" (W) x 6.9" | Weight (single pump): 12.5 oz | Battery life: 2 hours | Milk capacity: 4 oz. | Flange included: 24mm & 21mm inserts
Our product tester says:
“I didn’t notice any leaking while wearing it and bending over slightly, which is perfect for a mom with toddlers!”
Best innovative wearable breast pump
- Built-in warming technology
- Wireless charging case holds all pump parts
- Tester experienced higher milk output
- Customized pumping rhythms
- Tough to snap on flange shield
Since wearable breast pumps first came on the scene eight years ago, the industry hasn't stopped innovating. It seems like every year a new model comes out that's thinner or smarter or easier to use. But even in a constantly evolving market, the eufy Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro, our Best of The Bump winner for best innovative wearable breast pump, stands out. The pump has a unique warming feature that helped me produce just as much breast milk as my go-to electric pump. I consistently pumped about 4 ounces of breast milk in only 15 minutes each time I used these pumps—that’s huge for me, since I feed my son every two hours. The magic comes from the silicone flange backing that butts right up to your breasts. There are heating elements under the silicone that warm your breasts while you’re pumping. This was definitely a different kind of pumping experience, in a good way!
According to eufy, the warming effect prevents clogged ducts and boosts your milk output. I’ve never experienced clogs, but I did seem to pump more than expected based on how full my breasts were before pumping, so they might be onto something here. One thing I will note is that I found it a bit challenging to snap the flange shield onto the motor when assembling it—the warming element seems to require a tighter fit than most. Thankfully, there was a handy alert feature on the app that notified me if I didn’t fit it on properly before pumping. And while apps are pretty standard on wearable pumps, this was a good one. It allows you to tailor your pumping experience to your needs, customizing your rhythm, suction strength and speed on your phone for a truly hands-free experience.
Overall, this is a really neat pump. It’s easy to get started with an app that walks you through everything, and it’s oh-so cute—I really love the vibe eufy went for. The muted sand color can complement a wide range of personalities and aesthetic styles.
Dimensions (single pump): 5" (L) x 4.5" (W) x 2.5" (H) | Weight (single pump): 9.9 oz. | Battery life: 2.5 hours | Milk capacity: 5 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 17mm, 19mm and 21mm
Our product tester says:
“The heating aspect of this pump is unique—you won’t find that anywhere else. And something about that warming feature works because I pumped the most from this pump compared to the others I tested, easily.”
Overall best hands-free breast pump
- Tester saw an increase in milk output
- Only 3 parts that come in contact with milk
- Connector tubes were just the right length
- No carry bag included
With hands-free breast pumps, you get the portability of a fully wearable pump and the suction strength of an electric pump all in one. I can’t imagine toting my big, bulky electric pump around when I need full pumping sessions on the go—it’s just too much. That’s where the Momcozy V1 Pro comes into play. This pump, a Best of The Bump winner for overall best hands-free breast pump, has everything you need for a great pumping session: 300 mmHg hospital-strength suction, a whopping 15 levels of intensity, a leak-proof seal and a modern touchscreen, all with a motor the size of a hockey puck that can easily hang from your neck. It’s not large, but it's also not so small that it becomes difficult to change the pump’s settings. It was a bit of a bummer that it didn’t come with a carry bag, but you can easily toss it in your diaper bag for on-the-go pumping.
The pump was extremely easy to put together. Momcozy cleverly combined some pump parts that are normally separate pieces on competitor's hands-free options (for example, the diaphragm piece is built directly into the cup), which saves you some steps when assembling and cleaning the pump. In fact, there are only three parts per pump that you actually need to clean—huge mom win!
By far, the Momcozy V1 Pro is my favorite hands-free pump to date. Not only was everything lightweight, from the cups to the motor, but it was so easy to use. The motor has a lock feature on the touchscreen that auto-locks after a couple of seconds of not being touched, which was amazing because my son was feeding on the other breast and playing with the motor dangling from my neck. If it wasn't locked, he would have touched all the buttons and messed with my pumping settings.
To top it off, out of all the hands-free pumps I tested, this one produced by far the most milk for me. I was able to pump 5 ounces on each breast. That's a ton for me, since I'm either breastfeeding or pumping every two hours! With 15 levels of suction, three modes (stimulation, expression and a mixed mode) and three different rhythms, I was able to fine-tune this pump to exactly what I needed.
Dimensions (single pump): 2.8" (L) x 4.4" (W) x 4.8" (H) | Weight: (motor) 9.9 oz., (single cup) 4.2 oz. | Battery life: 4.5 hours | Milk capacity: 6 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 17mm, 19mm and 21mm
Our product tester says:
“It's easy to use with only three parts to wash, has 300 mmHg suction power and is so lightweight I wasn't uncomfortable at all. This is my new favorite hands-free pump. I can't believe how much I actually pumped with it.”
Best budget-friendly hands-free breast pump
- Strong performance at a lower price
- Lightweight
- Quiet, discreet pump
- Some moms report leaks
- Suction was a little intense for our sensitive product tester
There’s no question about it, pumps can be expensive. What's more, some insurance plans consider hands-free and wearable pumps an upgrade item, due to their higher costs, and may limit coverage to only standard electric models. I personally paid a pretty penny to upgrade my insurance pump to a more portable and wearable one. Then I learned about the Freemie Rose Pump, which is making hands-free pumping more accessible to moms. It has a relatively inexpensive cost, with easy assembly and a low noise level, earning it a top spot as our Best of The Bump winner for best budget-friendly hands-free breast pump.
The first thing I wonder when I see a lower-priced breast pump is how well the quality holds up. Does it fit together seamlessly? Does it feel secure when it's set up? Thankfully, our product tester and fellow mom Mindy, mama to a 1-month-old baby, raved about the Freemie Rose’s easy assembly: “This pump was easy to put together and the pieces snapped in perfectly; being able to put it together and disassemble quickly is great.” And while she mentions that she had a little difficulty understanding the pump control at first, she says the pump worked really well once she got the hang of the “quick pulsation for stimulation and then let down.”
More importantly, Mindy tells us this pump worked just as well as more expensive options she’s tried. “This pump felt pretty effective in removing my milk. Compared to other pumps, I removed about the same I would expect,” she says. “The cups fit well into a typical nursing/pumping bra, so I felt like I could move around with it well.”
As you might expect, Mindy gave the Freemie Rose Pump a 10 out of 10 rating for value for money—at under $150, it's a great price point for a hands-free pump. But it also received a perfect score for its style and design. This mother of a newborn felt that not only was the pink color aesthetically pleasing, but the bright color made it easier for her to keep track of the pump’s parts! In this case, affordable doesn’t need to mean boring or cheap.
Dimensions (pump): 7.7" (L) x 5.6" (W) x 4.5" (H) | Weight (motor): 9 oz., (single cup) 2 oz. | Battery life: 2.5 hours | Milk capacity: 5 oz. per cup | Flanges included: 25mm and 30mm, 28mm inserts
Our product tester says:
“The pump is a nice size and was easy to clip to my pants to be able pump on the go or move around while pumping. I believe this pump will last me throughout my pumping journey.”
Best portable hands-free breast pump
- Lightweight, slim motor
- Comes with a lanyard and carry bag
- Very high suction strength
- Silicone flange backing
- Connectors are a bit confusing to figure out at first
- Can be powerful for sensitive nipples
- Cups sold separately
If you want the portability of wearable cups but the intense pumping power of an electric pump, BabyBuddha offers wearable Collection Cups (purchased separately) to match its lightweight BabyBuddha 2.0 hands-free pump. Weighing only 6.3 ounces (at least 20 percent lighter than other hands-free motors we tested), the BabyBuddha 2.0 motor also has a slim profile, and yet it performs like a powerhouse wall pump. I thought the pump’s motor was super easy to hold onto since it was shaped like a phone. You can easily hold it in the palm of your hand and select your settings, or hang it from your neck with the included lanyard, or even slip it into a pocket! This means you can put on BabyBuddha’s wearable cups under your shirt, slide the motor in your pocket and have a discreet pumping session all on the go. As a busy mom of two who feeds and pumps every two hours, that’s much appreciated, and earned this combo our Best of The Bump award for most portable hands-free pump.
The motor may be small and portable, but that doesn’t detract in any way from its power: At 320 mmHg suction strength, this is one of the strongest wearable pumps I’ve tested to date. It has nine expression suction levels, although it was plenty strong for me at level two. But while the suction power can be intense, I stayed comfortable during my pumping sessions thanks to the 100 percent silicone flange backing, which is really soft. I expressed quite a bit of milk each time I used it too—about 4 ounces from each breast. The motor also offers six levels of soft stimulation and six levels of classic stimulation, so you can choose which kind of stimulation you like for a more efficient letdown.
To me, everything about the BabyBuddha 2.0 with the additional wearable cups gives off high-quality vibes. The cups are thicker, and so are the silicone backing parts. Not to mention, at 8 ounces per cup, there's a pretty high milk capacity! And when you’re holding the motor, it just feels so solid and sturdy. I can see this lasting throughout many pumping journeys and different babies.
Dimensions (single pump): 6" (L) x 6" (W) x 4" (H) | Weight (motor): 6.8 oz., (single cup) 4 oz. | Battery life: 60 minutes | Milk capacity: 8 oz. per pump | Flanges included: 17mm, 19mm and 21mm
Our product tester says:
“I love how small and hand-held the motor is, and how straightforward the buttons are. It really did a great job at suctioning out my breast milk, fast.”
Best quiet hands-free breast pump
- Extremely quiet
- Our product tester pumped a higher volume of milk than with other pumps she’s tried
- Small motor
- Some moms had difficulty with suction after extended use
I’ve used my fair share of pumps that sound like you’re walking through a machinery plant—and that loud racket can be a real detractor, whether you’re trying to pump in your office, on the go or near your sleeping baby. Enter the Spectra 9 Plus. One of the best features of this Best of The Bump-winning pump is its hard-working yet ultra-quiet motor, which delivers solid milk production without excessive noise. Our product tester, Kayla, who gave this pump a 10 out of 10 score for effectiveness and noise, tells us, “It was definitely quieter than I expected,” and deemed it ideal for pumping after going back to work.
Kayla was also impressed with the volume of milk she produced with Spectra 9 Plus, thanks to its hospital-strength suction power. While she was able to produce between 2 to 3 ounces of milk per breast with other pumps, she got 4 ounces per side from the Spectra 9 Plus. And the quality blew her away: “I absolutely love Spectra,” she says. “The pump parts are definitely high-quality and easy to use and wash. I love that the parts can be used for months before being replaced.” As a mom of three, she also appreciated that the small motor fit right into her pocket, so she could go about her busy day unrestrained.
Dimensions (pump): 2.8" (L) x 1.9" (W) x 4.8" (H) | Weight (motor): 9.4 oz., (single cup) 3.5 oz. | Battery life: 2.5 hours | Milk capacity: 5 oz. | Flanges included: 24mm and 28mm
Our product tester says:
“It was definitely quieter than I expected. This is perfect for when I need to pump on the go or when I’m back in my office.”
Wearable and Hands-Free Breast Pump Comparison Chart
| Overall best wearable breast pump | Best budget-friendly wearable breast pump | Most discreet wearable breast pump | Best quiet wearable breast pump | Best leak-proof wearable breast pump | Best innovative wearable breast pump | Overall best hands-free breast pump | Best budget-friendly hands-free breast pump | Best portable hands-free breast pump | Best quiet hands-free breast pump | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Overall Best ![]() Lansinoh DiscreetDuo Wearable Pump | ![]() MomMed S21 Wearable Breast Pump | ![]() Momcozy Air 1 Ultra-slim Breast Pump | ![]() Elvie Wearable Double Electric | ![]() Willow 360 Wearable Double | ![]() eufy Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro | ![]() Momcozy V1 Pro | ![]() Freemie Rose Pump with SlimFit5 Cups | ![]() BabyBuddha 2.0 with Hands-Free Breast Pump Collection Cups | ![]() Spectra 9 Plus with CaraCups | |||
| Price | $ | $ | $$ | $$ | $$$ | $$ | $$ | $ | $$ | $$ | ||
| Weight | 8 oz. per pump | 8 oz. per pump | 9.8 oz. per pump | 8 oz. per pump | 12.5 oz. per pump | 9.6 oz. per pump | 9.9 oz. (motor) | 8.3 oz. per cup | 6.8 oz.(motor) | 8.4 oz. (motor) | ||
| Milk capacity | 6 oz. | 6 oz. | 6 oz. | 5 oz. | 4 oz. | 5 oz. | 6 oz. | 5 oz. | 8 oz. | 5 oz. | ||
| Battery life | 100 minutes | 2.5 hours | 3 hours | 2.5 hours | 2 hours | 2.5 hours | 4.5 hours | 2.5 hours | 1 hour | 2.5 hours | ||
| Auto shut off? | ||||||||||||
| Max suction | 260 mmHg | 220 mmHg | 280 mmHg | 220 mmHg | 245 mmHg | 300 mmHg | 300 mmHg | 280 mmHg | 320 mmHg | 270 mmHg | ||
| Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review |
“One of the biggest challenges for moms [when choosing a breast pump] is that they haven’t even narrowed down what they want infant feeding to look like for their family,” says Jessica Anderson, IBCLC, virtual lactation consultant and owner of Genuine Lactation. “Until we know what it is that you are trying to accomplish and what your family situation is, it’s really hard to recommend a specific medical device.” Allison Tolman, IBCLC, owner and lead breast pump expert and coach at New Little Life concurs, telling us that when she’s asked about the best breast pump, “my response to that is always—for what? What are you looking for? What’s important to you?” Each type of pump has its own pros and cons, and it’s worth considering them before you make your choice. It gets even more dicey when you’re thinking about very similar—but distinct—types of pump like wearable and hands-free.
Wearable and hands-free pumps are “kind of like rectangles and squares,” says Webb. They do similar things and look almost the same, but have a few key differences.
Wearable breast pumps
A wearable breast pump is a compact, self-contained device designed to fit discreetly inside a bra, allowing for pumping without the need to hold the device in place. Tolman defines a wearable as "a pump where the milk collection device and the motor can both fit inside the bra.” Anderson notes, “If the entire unit is contained within your bra, you are as least restricted by pumping that you could possibly be.”
However, the smaller motor can come at the cost of some efficiency and longevity. Wearable pumps are best suited for moms who need flexibility in their routines—the main benefit they offer is portability and convenience. “One of my favorite uses for a wearable pump is if a mom is struggling to keep up her pumping schedule. A wearable pump can be a nice supplement to help fill in the gaps,” says Tolman. These pumps often have a dual-motor system, offering higher suction, though suction varies by model.
Tolman offers a specific example of an ER doctor: If she were to recommend an electric pump alone to such a mom, the odds that she would meet her goal of pumping two to three times a day would be low—a busy doctor is unlikely to be able to sit and plug in for pumping sessions. This is an instance where Tolman would likely recommend using a wearable option to ensure session consistency. “It’s better to have more frequent, potentially less effective sessions than to be skipping sessions because the pump you have is creating too many barriers to get you sitting down,” says Tolman. In some cases, the tradeoff of using a wearable pump—which might not be as powerful as a traditional pump—may be worth it for its convenience and flexibility. This approach can allow moms to pump more regularly, even if each session is shorter or less efficient, rather than skipping sessions altogether due to logistical difficulties.
Pros:
- Discreet. “A wearable pump can work really well for moms who need something discreet,” says Tolman. The compact design allows for more privacy and freedom, making it easier to pump while on the go.
- Convenient. Since the wearable pump fits discreetly inside a bra, it frees up the user’s hands and body, offering comfort and flexibility to go about their day without being restricted by tubes or cords.
- Enables multitasking. Even more than hands-free breast pumps, wearable pumps allow moms to pump while doing other activities, whether at work, at home, or while running errands, without the need to be tethered to a traditional pump setup.
- Portable. These pumps are compact and easy to transport, making them ideal for moms who are frequently on the move or need to pump outside the home. They’re an excellent choice for traveling or when working in different environments.
Cons:
- Less efficient. “Wearable pumps often tend to be less efficient than a traditional pump,” says Tolman. They may not offer the same level of suction or milk output as larger, traditional pumps. “Wearables are always going to provide less efficiency just because of the nature of the compression of the breast tissue,” says Anderson.
- Creates challenges with flange sizing. Finding the right fit for a wearable pump may be trickier since the pump is hidden inside the bra, making adjustments more difficult. “Flange sizing is more challenging because you can’t see anything,” says Tolman.
- Creates less focus during sessions. “The way that a wearable pump is designed to be used, moms are paying less attention to what’s happening during a session,” notes Tolman. This lack of focus may reduce efficiency since there’s less intentional engagement with the process.
- Less durable. It’s not uncommon for wearable pumps to wear out before a year of consistent use. “The tiny motor only goes so far,” says Tolman, meaning the pumps may lose efficiency or break down faster than electric pumps.
Hands-free breast pumps
A hands-free breast pump is almost like a midpoint between wearable and electric pumps. They’re smaller and more portable than an electric breast pump, and designed to work with a pumping bra so moms can pump without having to hold the device in place. As Anderson points out, this design allows mothers to perform other tasks while pumping “versus holding the flanges to the body,” providing more freedom and convenience. This setup makes hands-free breast pumps well-suited to moms who multitask during pumping sessions.
The term “hands-free” can be a bit misleading—these designs aren’t quite as portable as wearable pumps, as hands-free breast pumps typically have an external motor, connected by tubing, instead of an all-in-one design. The larger, external motor typically offers more power than a wearable pump, but the tubing can get in the way. Hands-free pumps offer much of the efficiency of an electric pump without tying you to one task, but depending on the design you may not be easily running around the house or office while pumping as you could with a wearable.
Pros:
- Portable. Hands-free pumps are typically more portable and easy to move around than electric breast pumps.
- Enables multitasking. You can perform other activities without having to hold the flanges in place.
- Traditional flange design. These pumps often use traditional flanges, offering some of the effectiveness of a standard pump with the added benefit of being more mobile.
Cons:
- You have to deal with tubing. “Tubing can be annoying and cumbersome,” says Anderson. The extra parts needed for the pump to function can get in the way, especially if you’re moving around a lot, making it less convenient than a truly portable, wearable pump.
- External motor. Since the motor is external, it can still be bulkier and heavier than wearable pumps. This may limit some mobility, especially if you need to be discreet or move around a lot.
- Longer setup time. Unlike wearable pumps, which are self-contained and easy to use with minimal setup, hands-free pumps may require more time to get everything in place (like attaching flanges and tubing, and securing the pump to a bra).
- Not completely hands-free. While they allow for some hands-free use, you still need to attach and adjust the pump properly. This can be more involved than a wearable pump, which fits directly inside a bra with minimal adjustment.
Wearable and hands-free pumps are super convenient when you need to tackle other tasks. I’ve pumped while working, gardening, doing the dishes, out at dinner and even in the car. They’re the modern mom’s life-savers. Meema Spadola, a certified lactation counselor in Brooklyn, New York, says, “If you’re pumping milk for your newborn while needing to care for your older child or children, being able to wear the pump without any tubing or electrical cord getting in the way is a huge relief. (It’s hard to imagine reading bedtime stories and cuddling with a toddler while pumping with a traditional pump!)"
That being said, Spadola tells us that a lot of what you want to look for in a wearable or hands-free pump is similar to a traditional pump—qualities like effectiveness at removing milk and leak-proof construction are important to watch out for. But she also stressed that perhaps even more than with a traditional pump, you have to think about comfort. “I really do wish that people could try before they buy,” she tell us, “since a pump that might be comfortable for one person might be really uncomfortable for a different user, and that connects very directly to how effective a pump will be at removing milk!”
Before you blindly pick out a pump, take the time to consider your needs. Here are a few factors to consider before you buy:
- Weight. A hands-free or wearable pump is worn in your bra, so it needs to be lightweight. Fortunately, these devices are designed to be small and compact, with some wearable options weighing under a pound.
- Noise. All breast pumps make some noise, but some options are louder than others. If you’re planning to use the pump at home, noise level may not be a major concern. But if you want to use it on plane trips, during work calls or when you’re out with friends, it’s best to opt for a quieter model.
- Level of discretion. Wearable breast pumps sit fully inside your bra, with no tubing sticking out—but they tend to cost more than a hands-free option with a separate motor. If you’ll be pumping at home, you may not be after complete subtlety, but if you plan to be in public view, opting for something that’s practically invisible may be worth the price.
- Suction speed. Speed and power are key factors when it comes to purchasing a breast pump. People that are trying to boost their milk supply may need a hospital-grade pump that sucks faster and at a higher frequency, whereas others may fare well with a standard pump. Suction is usually measured in mmHg and ranges from around 220 to 350, which is the highest level available.
- Cost. Wearable models have traditionally been the most expensive type of breast pump available—although their price has come down in recent years. When we started testing these products two years ago, a double wearable pump would run you over $500, but nowadays there’s a range of price points to choose from. You can even contact your insurance provider to see what’s covered under your specific health plan.
Webb’s advice? Get clear on your ideal feeding journey. “Not just with feeding your baby,” she says, “but what are your goals for your milk? Are you someone who wants to have a big freezer stash? [Or] are you okay with having just enough? Are you okay supplementing or using combination feeding?” She says the best way to figure that out is to chat with a lactation consultant. They’ve seen dozens of pumps and can help you lock down the right one for you.
The world of breast pumps has come a long way, and fast. The technology behind the pump I used with my first baby (just three years ago!) didn’t come close to what we have now. While traditional electric pumps used to be the go-to, wearable and hands-free options have quickly taken over as the most popular style on the market. Things really started to shift in 2017 when Willow came out with the first-ever wearable pump, shaking up the whole industry. Elvie followed hot on their heels in 2018, kicking off a new era of pump design. At the time, both pumps were game-changing but (as is usually the case with new technology) pretty pricey.
Since then, more affordable brands have hopped on the bandwagon. Momcozy, Legendairy Milk and Freemie have all stepped in with budget-friendly options, pushing Willow and Elvie to release lower-cost versions of their own. Even so, Willow and Elvie’s pumps still sit at the higher end of the price spectrum. And in a surprising twist, Elvie went into administration in March 2025—only for Willow to scoop up the brand, which they’re keeping active (at least for now).
In just the past year, there’s been so much innovation from these up-and-coming brands: Momcozy launched an ultra-slim wearable, eufy added warming tech and even Motif—usually known for electric pumps—jumped into the wearable game. It’s exciting to see what neat new pumps will take over next!
About the writer:
Dani Wolfe is a senior marketer and women’s health writer who is newly postpartum with her second child. She’s breastfed and pumped for two and a half years and counting, and knows what makes a great pump. After first becoming a mom in 2021, she craved advocacy in this space and strives to help other women feel supported through her work. She has a bachelor’s degree in science and a certification in holistic nutrition. Dani lives on Lake Michigan with her husband, 3-year-old daughter and 6-month-old baby boy.
The Bump thanks Christine Carpenter for invaluable contributions to this article. Christine is a New York-based journalist and a devoted mom of two young boys. With firsthand experience testing and using a wide range of breast pumps, she understands the challenges that moms face in finding the right pump for their unique needs. Drawing on her expertise in product development, Christine offers insightful, well-informed advice to help moms make the best choices for their breastfeeding journey.
Plus, more from The Bump:
Francie Webb, IBCLC, is a board-certified lactation consultant and the founder of Go Milk Yourself. The mom of three provides lactation care before and after birth and has worked with 1,600+ parents and provided training to 2,000+ professionals.
Jessica Anderson, MA, IBCLC, CLC, is the owner of Genuine Lactation, a virtual breastfeeding support service that offers online lactation support.
Allison Tolman, IBCLC, is a lactation consultant and coach at New Little Life and a former ob-gyn nurse with 15 years of experience helping new mothers navigate breastfeeding.
Meema Spadola is a postpartum doula and certified lactation counselor based in Brooklyn, New York.
The Bump May 2023 Survey. Editors conducted a survey of 300 new parents from among The Bump community, and asked whether they used a hands-free or wearable breast pump and what they did and didn’t like about it.
Target Baby Registry
Free $100+ Value Welcome KitFree $100+ Value Welcome Kit
15% Completion Discount15% Completion Discount
Free 1-Year ReturnsFree 1-Year Returns
20+ Exclusive 20% Off
Deals For Mom & Baby20+ Exclusive 20% Off Deals For Mom & Baby1:1 Concierge With
Baby Gear Specialists1:1 Concierge With Baby Gear Specialists

*Subject to availability and Retailer's terms.
We earn commissions from these links.



































































