Choosing the Best Diaper Subscription Service—With Help from Moms

Coterie Diapers have been Best of The Bump award-winners for three years in a row, and it’s easy to see why. Parents across The Bump community, including our product tester Julie, agree that these premium diapers offer superior absorbency. “The diapers were extremely absorbent, better than any diaper I've used. They did not leak once. No blowouts escaped them. I used them during the night, where she would go a 12-hour stretch without being changed. She sleeps on her belly, and still never had any leaking through,” Julie shared with us. This performance is backed up by Coterie’s lab testing, which revealed that their size 4 diapers hold more than 16 ounces of liquid.

Not only do Coterie diapers get the job done, but they’re ultra-comfortable as they do so. Each diaper is made from a hypoallergenic, apparel-grade fabric that’s 25 percent plant-based (and OEKO TEX Standard 100-certified), so you can count on them to be gentle on baby’s sensitive skin. Julie said the softness was one of the first things she noticed when opening these diapers. Plus, her 4-month-old “never seemed uncomfy in them, and they never left any red marks or irritation from the diaper leg cuffs like I’ve noticed other diapers have.” Overall, the quality and comfort Coterie offers stands out to say the least.

Subscription service

Coterie's subscription service allows parents to purchase a month’s worth of diapers at a time. The number of diapers you receive per shipment depends on the size that you order, ranging from 186 for newborn sizing (which comes out to about six diaper changes a day) and 96 for size 7 diapers (which is about four changes a day). Most subscriptions are set to auto-renew every four weeks. However, you can change this to three or five weeks by going into your account settings.

Coterie makes it easy to manage all the details of your diaper subscription, from product size to delivery date. In fact, you can adjust your preferences via text message at any hour of the day or night. (Coterie even breaks down their SMS commands to streamline the process further.) Two days before your next shipment is processed, you’ll receive a text and email reminders, allowing you to make any adjustments, whether that be sizing, shipping address or even delaying or skipping that order. By signing up for a diaper subscription service, you’ll receive 10 percent off—plus, if you bundle wipes, you’ll get free shipping. If at any point you want to end the subscription, you can do so by texting CANCEL to Coterie’s text assistant, canceling via your account page on Coterie’s website or email the team.

Delivery options: Every 3 to 5 weeks | Sizes: Newborn (under 10 lbs.) to 7 (41+ lbs.) | Shipping fee: $8 standard (2 to 6 business days); $25 express (2 to 3 business days) | Materials: Propylene (topsheet); polypropylene, polyester and polyethylene (backsheet); SAP and wood pulp (core); polypropylene/polyethylene (fastening system); polyester (acquisition layer)

Material is an important consideration when choosing the best diapers for your little one. That’s why Kudos takes pride in being the first to be lined with 100 percent cotton that’s sourced from the US and processed without water, chemicals or heat. This top sheet is OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified and made from 70 percent unbleached cotton. Our tester, Bernadette, was a big fan of this. “The soft, natural feel of the cotton on your baby's skin is gold compared to the plastic, chemical-treated materials of other disposable diapers,” she shared. “You can tell that it’s made from cotton because it isn't the bleached white color of disposable diapers, it’s more of a beige.”

Kudos Diapers also deliver big time on functionality. When testing these with her 5-week-old, Bernadette appreciated how simple they were to use, in part because of the stretchy yet snug waistband. “Late-night changes were easy because we could handle the package and diaper with one hand and with minimal lighting,” she shared. Better yet, the design’s two DoubleDry tech absorption layers kept her newborn comfortable, day and night. “We have not experienced any leakage overnight or during the day. Kudos have kept my baby dry in even the most full diaper situations [like] long drives.”

Subscription service

When signing up for a recurring order with Kudos you’ll save 12 percent, and you can choose between deliveries every three, four or five weeks. Packs range from 210 size 1 diapers to 120 size 6 diapers. To customize your preferences, simply log in to your account on the Kudos subscriptions portal page. Here, you’ll be able to reschedule upcoming orders, pause or cancel your subscription and change sizes as needed. If you need to make any last-minute edits to an order you recently placed, Kudos suggests emailing their team as soon as possible.

Delivery options: Every 3 to 5 weeks | Sizes: 1 (7-12 lbs.) to 6 (35+ lbs.) | Shipping fee: Free | Materials: 100% cotton (topsheet); wood pulp and SAP (core); polyethylene and PLA (backsheet); polyethylene/polyester (acquisition layer); PE/PP blend (outer cover); polypropylene (closure system); Hydrocarbon Resin (wetness indicator)

HealthyBaby was the first, and is still one of the only, diapers on the market to be EWG-verified, meaning they’re free from an extensive list of harmful ingredients. The Our Diapers line is also designed from plant-based materials and is OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 certified for added peace of mind. Nathalia, mom of a 4-month-old, was thoroughly impressed by how gentle these were during testing. “My daughter has very sensitive skin, and I have tried several brands. This one has been great for her skin. Her rash went away. She seems comfortable, and there are no signs of diaper rash or irritation anywhere,” she shared with us.

To top it off, parents can rely on HealthyBaby Our Diapers for top-notch absorbency—another important factor when it comes to preventing sensitive skin from becoming irritated. “The diaper is extremely absorbent and can go all night (12 hours) without any pee leaks,” said Nathalia. This performance can be attributed to the patented Magic Air Channels and FlashDry technology, which work together to distribute wetness while also absorbing and trapping moisture. Lastly, these diapers come in biodegradable packaging, which Nathalia was happy with. “I like that the package is made of paper, not only because it's more eco-friendly, but also because I can open it with one hand,” she told us, which is particularly helpful when baby is in tow.

Subscription service

With the HealthyBaby Our Diapers subscription service, you can enjoy 17 percent off each recurring order, whether you’re receiving 192 newborn diapers or 108 size 6 diapers. The brand offers flexible options, ranging from every two to five weeks, depending on your family’s needs. If you need to change your details at any point, all you have to do is log in to your account on HealthyBaby’s website and navigate to the “Manage Subscription” section. Here, you’ll be able to edit the diaper size, delivery frequency and your address. You can also skip or pause upcoming orders online. If you sign up for the SMS program, you can change subscription details via text as well.

Parents who sign up for HealthyBaby’s diaper delivery service will have exclusive access to the brand’s Grow with the Flow program, a month-by-month guide on baby’s development. An added bonus: You’re invited to share your child’s birthday or due date when subscribing to receive what the brand calls a “personalized experience based on baby’s age and stage of development.” And if you’re ordering for more than one child, you can add their details as well.

Delivery options: Every 2 to 5 weeks | Sizes: Newborn (6-10 lbs.) to 6 (32+ lbs) | Shipping fee: $7.95 | Materials: 50% polyethylene and 50% polypropylene (topsheet); 60% sodium polyacrylate and 40% wood pulp (core); 100% polypropylene (core wrap); 100% polyester (acquisition layer); 35% polyethylene, 35% polypropylene, 20% adhesive and 10% elastic polyurethane (leg cuffs); 55% polypropylene, 25% adhesive and 20% polyethylene (closing system); 45% plant-based polyethylene, 45% calcium carbonate, and 10% adhesive (backsheet); 45% polyethylene, 40% polyester and 15% organic cotton (outer cover)

Headquartered in New Zealand, Terra is a relatively recent addition to the US baby market. Since their stateside launch in June 2023, they’ve become a popular diaper brand, especially among parents looking for non-toxic, all-natural styles. Terra Premium Diapers are made from 85 percent plant-based materials, including woodchips sourced from the US, sugar cane from Northern Australia and bamboo from lush Asian forests. All of this results in a breathable design that’s free from harsh chemicals and super comfortable. According to our tester Jaclyn, “my baby has very sensitive skin, so I was really pleased with that aspect of the diaper and the ingredients used to make it. It was really soft, fragrance-free and felt great, which can be unique among eco-friendly diapers.”

Terra diapers may be soft, but it's not at the cost of performance. In fact, lab testing showed that their diapers dried completely in less than a minute after absorbing 8 ounces of water. That’s 13 times faster than other leading brands, and can in part be attributed to the super absorber pad and water/resistant top sheet. After testing these with her 5-month-old, Jaclyn praised the fit and absorbency of this design. “[These] diapers fit well in the back, front, and around the legs. Baby felt dry to the touch when changing,” she shared. Each diaper also has a plant-based wetness indicator to help parents see how much has been absorbed, and the patented 360-degree absorbency keeps sensitive skin dry for 12+ hours. Best of all, if you want to try these diapers out before committing to a whole box, Terra offers free sample packs in all sizes; the only cost you have to pay is the shipping fee.

Subscription service

By signing up for Terra’s diaper subscription box service, you’ll save 10 percent on recurring orders—plus, free shipping if you’re located in the contiguous US. Pack quantities from 192 newborn diapers to 96 size 6 training pants. No matter which you go with, the brand offers a wide range of delivery frequencies, including every two weeks, three weeks, one month or two months. To modify your details at any time, just go to your account. Once logged in, you can edit, skip or cancel your subscription as needed. And if you’re encountering any issues, Terra suggests contacting their team for assistance.

Delivery options: Every 2 weeks, 3 weeks, 1 month or 2 months | Sizes: Newborn (up to 11 lbs.) to 6 (35+ lbs.) | Shipping fee: Free | Materials: Wood pulp, SAP and tissue paper (core); 100% bamboo fiber (backsheet and leg cuffs); random copolymer extract (water-resistant sheet); polypropylene (tape fastening system and top sheet)