My Brest Friend vs. Boppy, Which Nursing Pillow is the Better Fit?
In a nutshell:
The My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow has a cult-like following for its wraparound back support and structured nursing comfort, which provides new parents with guesswork-free positioning. The Boppy New Nursing Pillow is more of a long-term, versatile choice, not quite as precise, but accommodating bottle feeding, nursing, tummy time and supported sitting.
If you’ve spent any time in The Bump community researching nursing pillows, you’ve inevitably landed on two names: Boppy and My Brest Friend. Half the forum will die on the Boppy hill while the other half swears by My Brest Friend—and when preparing for my own baby’s arrival, I found myself going down the same Boppy versus My Brest Friend rabbit hole. So I’m going to give you what I wish someone had given me: a breakdown between the two, with input from two independent testers, plus insights from lactation consultants and pediatric and adult physical therapists.
I used the Boppy from the newborn stage through tummy time and supported sitting—and I’d make the same choice again because I’m a sucker for multi-purpose baby gear. That said, a lot of my mom friends are My Brest Friend loyalists, and I get it: the back support and nursing comfort are unmatched. At the end of the day, these two pillows are not solving the same problem. The right one comes down to your body, your baby and what kind of support matters most to you. Let’s move out of the forum stalemate and compare the two.
My Brest Friend vs. Boppy Comparison Chart
| The Boppy Nursing Pillow | My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Overall Best ![]() Boppy New Nursing Pillow | ![]() My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow | ||
| Price | $ | $$ | |
| Dimensions | 19.5" (L) x 6" (W) x 16" (H) | 24" (L) x 28" (H) - 28" to 44" waist | |
| Weight | 2.9 lbs. | 1.8 lbs. | |
| Fill | Polyester | Polyurethane foam | |
| Cover material | 80% polyester/20% cotton | Polyester | |
| Strap/belt | |||
| Waterproof cover | |||
| Machine washable cover | |||
| Buy NowRead Full Review | Buy NowRead Full Review |
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow is a 6-inch, C-shaped pillow that rests on your lap.
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow is a firm, 5-inch flat foam platform that clips around your waist.
Shape and structure
The Boppy is instantly recognizable for its classic crescent shape with soft polyester fill that curves around your front without fastening. It’s at once unfussy and uber practical for slipping on in a pinch when baby needs feeding stat. “This nursing pillow is a very well-designed product,” affirms our product tester and mom to a 2-and-a-half-month-old, Tia M. “The sturdiness of the material inside is amazing. It has just enough give for you and your baby to have the comfort needed for breastfeeding.” No straps or belts necessary.
My Brest Friend, by contrast, features a firm foam core in the form of a flat, table-like platform with a 6-inch backrest that locks in with a silent buckle and velcro strap at the hip. Our product tester and mom to a 1-month-old, Katt M., said it hugged her body comfortably without feeling restrictive—even when she became nap-trapped for over an hour. And while the unique wraparound design instantly proved a big help with getting Katt into “the right feeding position for cradle hold,” the construction does more than keep her snugly supported. Built into the nursing pillow’s surface are two ‘feeding risers’ designed to lift baby’s head to better help ingestion and digestion.
Strapped-in support vs. strap-free freedom
A nursing pillow that sets you and baby up for success by virtue of its structure is no small thing and certainly not a design choice to take for granted. And it’s not by fans in The Bump Forum. “I LOVED My Brest Friend,” shares b.heather. “It straps around your waist and really holds baby up for nursing.” Fellow The Bump member, snansley agrees: “[my son] was on the smaller side and had some issues latching. The Brest Friend made things so much easier, and he didn’t fall off like he did on the Boppy.” Still, it has a very different feel from the Boppy, and it isn’t for everyone. Another Bump community member, who is a lactation consultant herself, found the wraparound fit too restrictive for her comfort, ultimately reaching for the Boppy instead. “For me, I didn’t like having to unstrap the Brest Friend every time I finished a feed,” she shares. “And it is much firmer (something I didn’t like, but can’t place why).”
Ultimately, the design difference comes down to feel. For nursing parents who want a little give with a lot more freedom, Boppy provides a sturdy, stiff fit in a strap-free package. And for those who long to be held by a wraparound structure, My Brest Friend’s purpose-built setup has your back.
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow is ready to use straight out of the box, though it may require slight position adjustments.
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow requires 12 to 24 hours to fully expand and a one-time strap adjustment, but once in use, our tester found it practically positioned baby for her.
Neither nursing pillow will have you flipping through an instruction manual. Tia simply washed the cover (which she noted was easy to take off and put back on) and started using it immediately. “I just placed the pillow on my body first and then leaned over to grab my baby,” she shares. Katt had a similar experience with My Brest Friend; she unpacked it right at feeding time and found that, even without instructions, she could use it right away. “It was very easy to set up,” she says. “The pillow kinda set you in the perfect position for baby to latch, which is impressive.”
Tia loved that the Boppy arrived pre-fluffed and ready to go. My Brest Friend, however, often needs 12 to 24 hours to air out and expand. Still, while it may need a little more prep, once it’s set up, it stays set. The same goes for the strap adjustment to fit your waist. “Once I adjusted the strap I don’t have to redo it again,” Katt adds.
When it comes to middle-of-the-night feeds, The Boppy may well be the winner here—its no-fasten design means you can grab it and get going with one hand while holding baby with the other. My Brest Friend requires both hands to wrap and buckle, but one Bump community member offered a workaround: “I would use it a lot for nighttime feedings by waking up, strapping it on, then going to get the baby,” shares b.heather. “That way you aren’t struggling in the dark to get a pillow positioned while holding your crying baby who just wants to eat.”
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow reduces strain by supporting baby at a breast height
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow adds structured, wraparound support that guides posture and takes pressure off the lower back
Both pillows reduce strain during feeding—but they do it differently, and the distinction matters depending on what kind of support you’re looking for. If you want support that feels flexible and pillow-like, the Boppy gets the job done. If you want something that actively corrects your posture and locks you into a healthy position, My Brest Friend may be the one for you.
According to Cate Schaffer Williams, PT, DPT, a physical therapist, pelvic floor therapist and clinic director at ATI Physical Therapy, the most common strain points in nursing parents are neck and back pain, pelvic floor tension and hand and wrist pain. The fix, she says, is straightforward in theory: “The pillow should work to bring the baby to Mom instead of Mom straining to get to the baby.”
The Boppy achieves this by elevating the baby to a consistent height, helping you avoid the nursing hunch or bracing with your arms. While it doesn’t force your posture, it provides enough of a lift to encourage sitting upright. Tia found it significantly better than other pillows. “With other pillows, I had to constantly adjust and ended up bending forward until my back and neck started to ache,” she says. “With this pillow, I could sit up almost straight and just look down slightly at my baby.” It was supportive enough that she even recommended it to her sister, who has chronic back pain.
My Brest Friend goes a step further. Its wraparound design tightens in place, eliminating any chance of a gap between pillow and body. Williams says a gap can cause parents to clench their knees, increasing tension through the abdomen and pelvic floor. The 6-inch backrest presses gently against the lower back, limiting hunching and allowing the shoulders to stay relaxed rather than tensing up. Katt felt the relief immediately. “Before trying this one I used something without the back supporter,” she tells us. “This pillow saves my back!”
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow is great for both bottle feeding and nursing
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow is best suited for nursing
Latch support
No nursing pillow—Boppy, My Brest Friend, or otherwise—should be relied on to achieve or fix latch issues, according to lactation consultants Shanon Berger and Liz Truesdale. However, both pillows can help by supporting the baby at breast height so you’re not hunching forward or holding all their weight.
The two pillows get you there differently. The My Brest Friend’s firm, 5-inch foam cushion acts like a table, keeping the baby parallel to your body so they don’t roll away. Katt found this “locked-in” setup kept her from slouching. The Boppy’s 6-inch crescent shape is designed to let the baby roll inward toward you. This creates the “belly-to-belly” contact Truesdale recommends, but it requires a snug fit. If the Boppy isn’t tucked tight against your waist, the curved surface can cause the baby to roll into the gap between the pillow and your body.
Both performed well in testing. “When you’re in the right setup, it helps support the baby’s weight and your back at the same time,” Katt says. Tia had an equally positive experience with the Boppy. “Using this nursing pillow made feeding much easier and comfortable.”
Bottle feeding
While both pillows technically work for bottle feeding, the Boppy is the clear winner in this arena. “One of my favorite bottle-feeding positions is to have the baby side-lying, and a nursing pillow is lovely in this situation,” Berger says. The Boppy’s softer cushion and open shape make bottle feeding positions more comfortable.
As for My Brest Friend, its rigid foam and wrap-around buckle are optimized for breastfeeding, and can feel stiff and restrictive for a bottle feed. The Boppy’s simple design also makes it easier to hand off to other caregivers. When using my own Boppy, I could hand my mom the Boppy, the baby and a bottle with zero instructions. Katt noticed the opposite with My Brest Friend: “The pillow fits my body perfectly, but it was awkward for my mom to use for a bottle.”
Positioning
My Brest Friend features a wrap-around, locked-in design that holds the pillow in a stable position with almost no effort from the parent. Combined with its firm “shelf” for the baby, it requires very little physical work for the nursing parent to keep everything in place. The Boppy can stay put, too, but because it doesn’t fasten, it relies heavily on your posture and the chair you’re sitting in to stay put.
Even if you feel a nursing pillow is secure enough for a hands-free moment, Truesdale reminds parents that these are meant to be support tools only. “The parent or support person should remain actively engaged and responsive during feeds—no matter how a baby is fed,” she says.
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow pulls double duty, not only working well for nursing, but for tummy time, supported sitting and more, well beyond the newborn stage
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow is built for nursing and excels at it, but its usefulness is limited to feeding
My Brest Friend is a nursing specialist; the Boppy is the generalist. Outside of nursing, My Brest Friend’s rigid structure and bulky footprint limit where and how it can be used while the Boppy’s softer, flexible surface can be adapted for tummy time, supported sitting and well beyond. One Bump community member says her older children still use hers for lounging on the couch. “I have two Boppys,” shares fellow Bump community member megpie10. “They are now in [my son’s] closet, he loves to lay on them while reading books.”
Tummy time
If your baby treats tummy time like a personal vendetta, has reflux or low muscle tone, Brenda Sacino, PT, DPT, CBS, an infant physical therapist and certified breastfeeding specialist, recommends trying a modified tummy time—propping baby on a nursing pillow. “Softer pillows such as the Boppy are more well-suited for this than My Brest Friend,” she says.
I got more mileage out of my Boppy during tummy time than almost anything else—my daughter actually tolerated it, dare I say even enjoyed it. “It can be most beneficial to position baby with their shoulders above their hips, essentially modifying tummy time as we would modify a plank position as adults,” Sacino explains.
Supported sitting
Once baby has strong head and neck muscles and can hold their head up—typically around 4 months old—you can use a Boppy to put baby in a supported seated position. Placing the nursing pillow in front of baby over their legs and against their belly gives them a spot to rest their forearms. This encourages them to lean forward and push through their arms, which is how they start building the strength to sit up all on their own. “The Boppy is what I use most here,” Sacino says. “I haven’t used the My Brest Friend for sitting support because it is so stiff—I don’t think My Brest Friend would work as well here.”
Portability
Katt found My Brest Friend too large for her rocking chair, opting instead for the bed or floor for nursing sessions, and opted to keep it in one room. “Even though it’s so light, it is bulky,” she says. The Boppy is easier to move around—I carried mine from the living room to the nursery to the playroom without much thought, and it worked comfortably on my couch or rocker. Tia preferred a firm couch or bed for the best support. I never traveled with mine, but it’s easy enough to tuck under an arm.
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow: Polyester fill with a removable 80% polyester/20% cotton cover. Machine washable, not waterproof.
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow: Polyurethane foam core with a removable 100% polyester waffle cover and integrated waterproof liner. Machine washable.
Both pillows have removable, machine-washable covers, but My Brest Friend’s integrated waterproof liner prevents messes from reaching the foam core. The Boppy’s cover doesn’t repel spills, which neither Tia nor I loved. “I did feel a little wetness on the pillow once I removed the cover,” Tia says. Messes didn’t turn out to be a headache for me, but if your baby frequently spits up, that extra layer of protection from My Brest Friend can make cleanup a lot easier. Tia, on the other hand, isn’t worried about Boppy’s durability or the upkeep. “With enough care and cleanings, this pillow will last a long time,” she says. If your baby is a heavy spitter or has reflux, the Boppy Uplift Nursing Pillow is worth a look. It has our vote as the best nursing pillow for reducing spit up because the elevated, wedge-shaped design keeps baby at a slight incline during feeds.
Tia appreciated that the Boppy Nursing Pillow’s polyester-cotton cover felt soft, not scratchy, and neither of us noticed any irritation on our babies’ skin—even during longer feeds. If that’s a concern, though, covers also come in 100% organic cotton. My Brest Friend has a waffle-textured cover with a classic look that Katt liked, but it did leave light imprints on her baby’s face. “There’s no irritation, just a mark,” she says.
Both covers unzip easily for washing, but getting them back on is a different story. Tia had no trouble with the Boppy’s snug-fitting cover, while Katt had a bit of a wrestle with her My Brest Friend after washing. She also noticed some pilling after laundering.
At a Glance
- Boppy New Nursing Pillow: $49.99
- My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow: $68.95
As of this writing, the My Brest Friend runs about $19 more than the Boppy—a difference worth weighing against how much use you’ll get out of each. The Boppy is designed for use from birth through 12+ months, and many parents find themselves reaching for it for much more than feeding.
My Brest Friend supports babies up to 20 pounds and 18 months, but many parents find they naturally transition away from it well before that, once breastfeeding becomes more established and baby grows heavier and more mobile.
If you want one pillow that can do a bit of everything—nursing, bottle feeding, tummy time, supported sitting and easy handoffs—the Boppy New Nursing Pillow is the more versatile pick. It’s the one you’re likely to keep using well beyond the newborn stage.
If your priority is comfortable, well-supported nursing—especially in those early weeks—the My Brest Friend Super Deluxe Nursing Pillow stands out. Its structured, wraparound design does more of the postural work for you, which many parents find makes a noticeable difference.
Still can’t decide? You wouldn’t be the first to own both. Parents in The Bump community with both often reach for My Brest Friend for nursing sessions and Boppy for everything else.
- Works for nursing and bottle feeding
- Easy to hand off to caregivers
- Doubles as tummy time support
- Great for early sitting support
- Cover is not waterproof
- Relies on posture to stay put
- Baby can roll into gap if mispositioned
Taking the best overall nursing pillow title for the second year running, the new and improved Boppy features a slightly firmer, higher cushion that keeps baby at the right height for bottle or breastfeeding—saving your back from the nursing hunch. Plus, the signature U-shape is now wider and more flexible to fit more parents comfortably without losing that classic hug. Same Boppy we love, but better.
Weight: 2.9 lbs. | Dimensions: 19.5" (L) x 6" (W) x 16" (H) | Fill material: Polyester | Outer fabric: 80% polyester/20% cotton | Removable cover: Y | Machine washable cover: Y
Our product tester says:
“The construction of this pillow is perfect for breastfeeding mothers. It has the give to wrap around your waist with the firmness and stiffness to support a baby once in feeding position.”
- Wraparound strap stays put
- Built-in 6-inch lumbar backrest
- Flat surface keeps baby parallel
- Waterproof liner protects foam core
- Not ideal for bottle feeding
- Too bulky to fit some nursing chairs
- Cover is tricky to put back on
The My Brest Friend's wraparound, clip-in design literally tethers the support to you, creating a stable "shelf" that won't shift or sag no matter how much baby wiggles or weighs. The built-in 6-inch backrest supports spinal alignment while the flat feeding surface keeps baby parallel for a more consistent latch. The waterproof liner is the cherry on top. This pillow was made specifically for nursing, and it shows.
Weight: 1.8 lbs. | Dimensions: 24" (L) x 28" (H) - 28" to 44" waist | Fill material: Polyurethane foam | Outer fabric: Polyester | Removable cover: Y | Machine washable cover: Y
Our product tester says:
“Definitely a big help, especially if your baby is having a hard time latching. It wraps around my body and gives me the right position for cradle hold feeding.”
About the writer:
Janelle Leeson is a mom of one based in Portland, Oregon, with a background in biology and a passion for helping parents navigate early motherhood. She nursed her daughter for over 12 months—and loved watching her own mother bottle feed and hold her, all made easier by a great nursing pillow, including the Boppy featured in this article. Along with her lived experience, Janelle has a knack for deep research and expert interviews, translating clinical advice into real-life tips and guidance for real parents.
Plus, more from The Bump:
Expert interviews:
Cate Schaffer Williams, PT, DPT, is a physical therapist, pelvic floor therapist and clinic director at ATI Physical Therapy.
Shanon Berger, IBCLC, RN, is an international board certified lactation consultant and registered nurse at Our Milk House. She has over 20 years of experience working in reproductive health, as a poostpartum nursing, lactaction consultant, doula, childbirth educator and L&D.
Liz Truesdale, BSN, RN, IBCLC, PMH-C, is a registered nurse and board-certified lactation consultant with a background in labor and delivery and mother-baby nursing.
Product testers:
Tia M., mom to a 2-and-a-half-month-old at the time of testing
Katt M., mom to a one-month-old at the time of testing
Target Baby Registry
Free $100+ Value Welcome KitFree $100+ Value Welcome Kit
15% Completion Discount15% Completion Discount
Free 1-Year ReturnsFree 1-Year Returns
20+ Exclusive 20% Off
Deals For Mom & Baby20+ Exclusive 20% Off Deals For Mom & Baby1:1 Concierge With
Baby Gear Specialists1:1 Concierge With Baby Gear Specialists

*Subject to availability and Retailer's terms.
We earn commissions from these links.























































