Buying vs. Renting a Breast Pump

To buy or to rent? It can be a tough choice—so we break down the pros and cons of each option.
save article
profile picture of Erin Walters
Updated April 27, 2017
Hero Image

The breast pump decision can be tricky, so it’s great that you’re weighing your options. First, ask yourself how long, why, where and how often you plan to pump. Each of these answers can make a big difference in whether a purchase or rental makes most sense for you, your pocketbook and baby. Once you’ve got a pumping plan in mind, look over the facts below to figure out which option best suits you.

Pump Rental

Cost: About $50 per month or $1 to $3 per day, plus $50 to purchase a kit with breast shields, tubing and bottles.

Where to rent: Your hospital or local lactation consultant may have rentals, or they can you refer you to the nearest rental facility. You can also search rental locations at Ameda or Medela’s website.

What you’ll get: A hospital-grade electric machine, probably with “double collection” (nurses both breasts at once), that plugs into the wall and is designed with more powerful motors than most personal pumps. You’ll need to buy the collection kit (parts that connect your breasts to the pump) separately. Hospital-grade rental pumps are fairly heavy and bulky but can help you produce the most milk in the shortest amount of time and are made with protective barriers to prevent cross-contamination between multiple users. It can cost more than $1,000 to purchase one of these machines now.

Why do it: Pump rental may be your best bet if you have needs that require more efficient pumping. If you have low milk supply, a premature baby, a baby that is unable to breastfeed, or if you have twins and need to produce double quantities, the  hospital-grade machine can be a huge help. Renting might also be your best (and most cost-effective) option if you still aren’t sure that pumping will be your thing or if you plan to pump for less than six months.

Related Video

Pump Purchase

Cost : About $50 for a simple hand pump, $100 to over $300 for a personal pump, and $1,000 or more for a hospital-grade pump.

Where to buy: You can purchase pumps at most of the same places where you purchase maternity clothes and baby gear, some department stores and even pharmacies.

What you’ll get: There are tons of options, ranging from hand-held pumps operated by squeezing a handle with one hand, to small battery-powered units, to single or double-breast electric plug-in machine with multiple settings complete with carrying cases and milk storage.

Why to do it: If you plan to pump longer than six months and have a healthy baby and good milk supply, it might be more cost effective to purchase a pump. Remember—you’ll be able to use it with future children, too. If you’ll be pumping at the office, personal pumps are much easier to lug around than the bulkier hospital variety. The small hand-held pumps are also a cost-effective alternative if you plan to pump only occasionally.

No matter which way you go, there are a few more important factors to consider. First, it’s best not to buy or borrow a used pump due to the risk of cross-contamination. (Hospital-grade rentals are built with protective barriers and approved by the FDA for multiple users.) Also, check your insurance policy—it may cover some of the pump rental or purchase cost, especially if you or baby has a condition that makes breastfeeding difficult.

save article

Next on Your Reading List

Best Baby Playpens Hero
6 Best Baby Playpens, Tested by Parents and Their Toddlers
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
Best Table Booster Seats-hero
The Best Table Booster Seat Styles, Tested by a Mom of Two
By Elizabeth Narins
baby sitting in high chair at table outside
The Best Portable High Chair Options, According to a Mom of Two
By Elizabeth Narins
Parent smiling at child in the stroller
6 Best Stroller Fans, Tested by a Cool and Comfortable Toddler
By Korin Miller
Toddler wearing headphones
6 Top-Rated Toddler Headphones
By Martina Garvey
Bye-Bye Baby Vibes: 9 Trendy Products for Your Mini-Me
By Elizabeth Nelson
mom and baby sitting in grass during springtime
The Best Amazon Big Spring Sale Deals for the Whole Family
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
Stroller Hero
Mom of a 2-Month-Old Put the Nuna MIXX Next Stroller to the Test
By Martina Garvey
snoo smart sleeper bassinet on sale rental 2022
Get the Cult-Favorite SNOO for 25 Percent Off Right Now
By Wyndi Kappes
mother using laptop while sitting next to baby in pack and play
The Best Pack and Plays and Playards, Tested by Active Kiddos
By Lauren Levinson
mother buckling baby into infant car seat
The 9 Best Infant Car Seats, Based on Parent Testing
By Elizabeth Narins
One Mom’s Honest Review of the SNOO Smart Sleeper Bassinet
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
mockingbird single to double stroller
Mockingbird Single-to-Double Stroller Review From Mom of Two
By Martina Garvey
The 11 Best Baby Play Mats for Tummy Time and Beyond
By Korin Miller
The Best Toddler Suitcases for Little Frequent Flyers
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
best learning towers for toddlers 2023
The 6 Best Toddler Tower Designs for Independent Tots
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
mother using changing table to change baby's diaper
The Best Changing Tables for Baby’s Nursery
By Martina Garvey
Best Travel System Strollers-hero
Best Stroller-Car Seat Combos and Travel Systems
By Martina Garvey
Best travel bed-hero
10 Best Toddler Travel Bed Options for Safe Slumber on the Go
By Lynsey Eidell
uppababy vista v2 stroller with bassinet
The Best Bassinet Strollers for Newborns and Infants
By Emma O'Regan-Reidy
Article removed.
Article removed.
Name added. View Your List